Post job

Employee reviews

4.27/5

Out of 11 American Family Insurance reviews, 82% were positive.

5 stars

4 stars

3 stars

2 stars

1 star

Based on 11 ratings

Overall rating
4.3
Salary and benefits
4.5
Work environment
3.8
Management
3.5
Career opportunities
3.8
Diversity and inclusion
4.0
Work at American Family Insurance?
Share your experience

American Family Insurance reviews

Employee reviews
profile
4.0
A zippia user wrote a review on Jul 2024
Pros of working at American Family Insurance

I thought the pay and benefits were solid for the workload. Many individuals were also great to work with.

Cons of working at American Family Insurance

Leaders lacked vision and would leave groups in the lurch for months and months without direction. There was also pretty much no accountability for poor performance and innovation was really theater and not something leaders leaned into.

American Family Insurance benefits

401k, pension, and healthcare were all pretty good.

What do you like best about American Family Insurance's CEO and the leadership team?

They showed genuine interest in social causes.

How would you improve American Family Insurance's culture?

Everything is so beaurocratic and hierarchical that things move very slowly. There needs to be more empowerment and comfort taking measured risks.

How did you prepare for the American Family Insurance interview?

Prepared answers to common questions of accomplishments, dealing with challenges, etc.

How does your compensation at American Family Insurance compare to the industry average?

I think my compensation was likely in line with the industry for my role.

What's the diversity at American Family Insurance like?

Still likely majority white but they have been trying to hire more diverse talent.

What brings you the most joy at American Family Insurance?

Creating new solutions to difficult problems.

Is this useful?
profile
5.0
A zippia user wrote a review on Feb 2020
Pros of working at American Family Insurance

Diversity & Inclusion are high priorities in our company. Community outreach is how we give back. Premiums mean something more than profits.

American Family Insurance benefits

My living wage, pension, 401k match, and tuition reimbursement.

Is this useful?
profile
3.0
A zippia user wrote a review on Feb 2020
Pros of working at American Family Insurance

Most of the people I work with

Cons of working at American Family Insurance

I work all the time. After a full day in the office I usually have to log on at night and most weekends. Absolutely no work life balance

American Family Insurance benefits

The location I work at is very close to my home.

Is this useful?
profile
5.0
A zippia user wrote a review on Mar 2019
Pros of working at American Family Insurance

My Team & helping our customers. Freedom of working in the field.

Cons of working at American Family Insurance

Audits & answering Insurance Department complaints.

American Family Insurance benefits

Working out of my house.

Is this useful?
profile
5.0
A zippia user wrote a review on Jul 2020
Pros of working at American Family Insurance

we are encouraged to follow our dream and the support to reach our personal goals are nurtured and facilitated

Is this useful?
profile
5.0
A zippia user wrote a review on Aug 2020
Pros of working at American Family Insurance

Availability for training, support center, flexible fridays

Cons of working at American Family Insurance

Growth minimized

American Family Insurance benefits

Flexible fridays

Is this useful?
profile
5.0
A zippia user wrote a review on Jul 2020
Pros of working at American Family Insurance

we are encouraged to follow our dream and the support to reach our personal goals are nurtured and facilitated

Is this useful?
profile
4.0
A zippia user wrote a review on Aug 2019
Pros of working at American Family Insurance

Convenient location and schedule. Generous time off.

Cons of working at American Family Insurance

Lack of opportunities for advancement

American Family Insurance benefits

Pension, 4 day work week

Is this useful?
profile
5.0
A zippia user wrote a review on Mar 2019
Pros of working at American Family Insurance

My Team & helping our customers. Freedom of working in the field.

Cons of working at American Family Insurance

Audits & answering Insurance Department complaints.

American Family Insurance benefits

Working out of my house.

Is this useful?

Rate the responsiveness of American Family Insurance to employee reviews.

Zippia waving zebra
Work at American Family Insurance? Share your experience

Zippia score

American Family Insurance salaries

9.0
Salary score
The national average salary for an American Family Insurance employee in the United States is $52,133 per year or $25 per hour. Employees in the top 10 percent can make over $97,000 per year, while employees at the bottom 10 percent earn less than $27,000 per year.

American Family Insurance demographics summary

9.8
Diversity score
We calculated the diversity score of companies by measuring multiple factors, including the ethnic background, gender identity, and language skills of their workforce

American Family Insurance financial performance

9.8
Performance score
We calculated the performance score of companies by measuring multiple factors, including revenue, longevity, and stock market performance.

Do you work at American Family Insurance?

Did the American Family Insurance act on employee feedback?