American Family Insurance claims manager salary

Zippia score 4.5

Average American Family Insurance claims manager salary

$98,888yearly

$35.27 hourly rate

Entry-level American Family Insurance claims manager salary

$77,000 yearly

Updated April 5, 2024

How much does American Family Insurance pay claims managers?

The average salary for American Family Insurance claims managers is $98,888 per year. American Family Insurance claims manager salaries range between $77,000 to $126,000 per year. American Family Insurance claims managers earn 35% more than the national average salary for claims managers of $73,369.

Location impacts how much a claims manager at American Family Insurance can expect to make. Claims managers at American Family Insurance make the most in Boston, MA, Chicago, IL, and Denver, CO.

How much does American Family Insurance pay claims managers by location?

American Family Insurance pays claims managers the most in Boston, MA, Chicago, IL, and Denver, CO. Additionally, cities like Portland and Saint Louis also report highly competitive salaries for claims managers at American Family Insurance.

Claims manager American Family Insurance salary by location

Rank	City	Avg. salary	Hourly rate
1	Boston, MA	$115,445	$55.50
2	Chicago, IL	$108,910	$52.36
3	Denver, CO	$105,970	$50.95
4	Portland, OR	$101,701	$48.89
5	Saint Louis, MO	$100,781	$48.45
6	Atlanta, GA	$100,651	$48.39
7	Jacksonville, FL	$100,639	$48.38
8	New York, NY	$99,847	$48.00
9	Los Angeles, CA	$98,702	$47.45
10	Phoenix, AZ	$97,897	$47.07

Highest-paid American Family Insurance claims managers by job level

Rank	Job title	Average salary	Hourly rate	Job openings
1	Senior Claims Analyst	$113,242	$54	-
2	Claims Director	$112,882	$54	-
3	Casualty Claims Supervisor	$110,781	$53	-
4	Claims Vice President	$107,021	$51	-
5	Liability Claims Manager	$102,738	$49	-
6	Claims Supervisor	$101,714	$49	-
7	Senior Claims Specialist	$98,006	$47	-
8	Senior Claims Examiner	$97,675	$47	-
9	Claims Account Manager	$86,545	$42	-
10	Senior Claims Representative	$72,906	$35	-

Show more salaries

Recent salaries for claims managers at american family insurance

Job	Location	Date added	Salary
Catastrophe Property Field Claims Manager	Madison, WI	04/28/2025	$86,000
Catastrophe Property Field Claims Manager	Saint Joseph, MO	04/26/2025	$86,000
Catastrophe Property Field Claims Manager	Phoenix, AZ	04/26/2025	$86,000
Catastrophe Property Field Claims Manager	Keene, NH	04/26/2025	$86,000
Catastrophe Property Field Claims Manager	Atlanta, GA	04/26/2025	$86,000

Claims manager salary at American Family Insurance competitors

Rank	Company	Average salary	Hourly rate	Job openings
1	Legg Mason	$112,960	$54	-
2	Citi	$103,090	$50	-
3	Liberty Northwest Insurance Corp	$99,731	$48	-
4	Prudential Retirement Insurance And Annuity Co	$96,383	$46	-
5	Liberty Mutual Insurance	$94,580	$45	139
6	Progressive	$87,322	$42	71
7	Piper Jaffray	$84,226	$40	-
8	Mutual of Omaha	$84,214	$40	-
9	BCS Financial	$83,132	$40	2
10	Farmers Insurance	$79,370	$38	28
11	Amica Insurance	$79,095	$38	1
12	Allstate	$75,489	$36	20
13	State Farm	$74,387	$36	1
14	Jackson	$73,778	$35	1
15	GEICO	$72,529	$35	31
16	Primerica	$72,357	$35	-
17	Aflac	$66,201	$32	-
18	Elevance Health	$60,531	$29	-
19	Shelter Insurance	$54,601	$26	9
20	UnitedHealth Group	$40,629	$20	-

Show more claims manager salaries at American Family Insurance competitors.