Post job

Average American Family Insurance salary in Madison, WI

$51,598yearly

$24.81 hourly rate

Entry-level American Family Insurance salary in Madison
$27,000 yearly
Updated April 5, 2024

How much does American Family Insurance pay in Madison, WI?

The average American Family Insurance salary in Madison, WI is $51,598. American Family Insurance salaries range between $27,000 to $96,000 per year in Madison. American Family Insurance Madison based pay is higher than American Family Insurance's United States average salary of $52,124. The best-paying job in Madison at American Family Insurance is sales producer, which pays an average of $158,251 annually.

American Family Insurance employees in Madison make $3,598 more than the average salary in Madison, $48,000.

American Family Insurance salaries in Madison, WI by job title

American Family Insurance’s highest-paying job in Madison, WI is sales producer, with an average salary of $158,251. The second highest is director, technical operations, which pays $152,941 annually in Madison, WI.

Highest paying jobs at American Family Insurance in Madison, WI

RankJob titleAvarage American Family Insurance salaryHourly pay
1Sales Producer$158,251$76
2Director, Technical Operations$152,941$74
3Lead Enterprise Architect$152,693$73
4Senior Technologist$136,434$66
5Technical Delivery Manager$133,990$64
6Marketing Director$130,740$63
7Director Of Enterprise Architecture$130,164$63
8Insurance Adviser$128,919$62
9Insurance Agent/Office Manager$128,154$62
10Engineering Specialist$125,791$60

American Family Insurance salaries in Madison, WI by department

The departments with the highest salaries for American Family Insurance employees in Madison are Engineering, IT, and Marketing.

Madison American Family Insurance employees in the Engineering department earn an average salary of $101,761 a year, compared to an average salary of $89,288 in the IT department and $81,170 in the Marketing department.

Highest-paying departments at American Family Insurance in Madison, WI

RankDepartmentAvarage American Family Insurance salaryHourly pay
1Engineering$101,761$49
2IT$89,288$43
3Marketing$81,170$39
4Plant/Manufacturing$79,932$38
5Finance$57,461$28
6Sales$55,627$27
7Administrative$36,199$17
8Customer Service$35,156$17

How much does American Family Insurance pay by city?

The cities near Madison, WI where American Family Insurance pays the highest salaries are Boston ($61,212), New York ($60,711), Seattle ($57,522), Portland ($53,893) and Denver ($53,053).

Highest-paying cities near Madison, WI at American Family Insurance

RankCityAvarage American Family Insurance salaryHourly pay
1Boston$61,212$29
2New York$60,711$29
3Seattle$57,522$28
4Portland$53,893$26
5Denver$53,053$26
6Minneapolis$52,473$25
7Chicago$52,158$25
8Madison$51,598$25
9Phoenix$51,179$25
10Atlanta$49,648$24

American Family Insurance’s competitor’s salaries in Madison, WI

The highest paying American Family Insurance competitor in Madison, WI is Legg Mason. The average salary at Legg Mason in Madison, WI is $158,251. The lowest paying American Family Insurance competitor in Madison, WI is Jackson.

Highest-paying American Family Insurance competitors in Madison, WI

RankCompany nameAvarage pay in Madison, WIHourly pay
1Legg Mason$75,858$36
2Piper Jaffray$69,103$33
3Citi$67,623$33
4BCS Financial$64,110$31
5Mutual of Omaha$63,117$30
6Prudential Retirement Insurance And Annuity Co$61,281$29
7Liberty Northwest Insurance Corp$58,926$28
8Liberty Mutual Insurance$57,296$28
9Elevance Health$57,267$28
10Jackson$57,189$27

Recently added American Family Insurance salaries in Madison, WI

JobLocationDate addedSalary
Lead EngineerMadison, WI06/30/2025$128,000
Actuarial AnalystMadison, WI06/30/2025$86,000
Research And Development TechnicianMadison, WI06/30/2025$86,000
Senior Manager, ProcurementMadison, WI06/30/2025$111,000
Staff SpecialistMadison, WI06/30/2025$78,000
Finance And Reporting AnalystMadison, WI06/30/2025$78,000
Senior Data Analyst-Madison, WI06/28/2025$78,000
Contact Center ManagerMadison, WI06/28/2025$68,000
Lead Network EngineerMadison, WI06/28/2025$128,000
Senior Product ManagerMadison, WI06/26/2025$128,000

Frequently asked questions about American Family Insurance pay in Madison, WI

Search for jobs