Post job
Updated April 5, 2024

Average American Family Insurance salary in New York

$60,709

$29.19 hourly

Entry-level American Family Insurance salary in New York

$32,000 yearly

How much does American Family Insurance pay in New York?

The average American Family Insurance salary in New York is $60,709. American Family Insurance salaries range between $32,000 to $112,000 per year in New York. American Family Insurance New York based pay is higher than American Family Insurance's United States average salary of $52,124. The best-paying job in New York at American Family Insurance is sales agent, which pays an average of $196,602 annually.

American Family Insurance salaries in New York by job title

American Family Insurance’s highest-paying job in New York is sales agent, with an average salary of $196,602. In second place is director of enterprise architecture, which pays $157,495 annually in New York.

Highest paying jobs at American Family Insurance in New York

RankJob titleAverage American Family Insurance salaryHourly pay
1Sales Agent$196,602$95
2Director Of Enterprise Architecture$157,495$76
3Registered Representative$157,279$76
4Director, Technical Operations$156,561$75
5Sales Leader$156,063$75
6Technical Manager$152,661$73
7Insurance Office Manager$141,188$68
8Support Manager$139,292$67
9Lead Enterprise Architect$138,963$67
10Technical Delivery Manager$137,958$66

Highest paying cities in New York for American Family Insurance

The highest paying cities in New York for American Family Insurance employees are New York, Buffalo, and undefined.

American Family Insurance workers in New York earn an average salary of $60,711 a year, compared to Buffalo with an average salary of $59,342 and undefined with an average salary of undefined.

Highest paying cities in New York at American Family Insurance

RankCityAverage American Family Insurance salaryHourly pay
1New York, NY$60,711$29
2Buffalo, NY$59,342$29

American Family Insurance salaries in New York by department

The departments with the highest salaries for American Family Insurance employees in New York are Engineering, IT, and Marketing.

New York American Family Insurance employees in the Engineering department earn an average salary of $115,098 a year, compared to an average salary of $101,965 in the IT department and $93,640 in the Marketing department.

Highest paying departments at American Family Insurance in New York

RankDepartmentAverage American Family Insurance salaryHourly pay
1Engineering$115,098$55
2IT$101,965$49
3Marketing$93,640$45
4Plant/Manufacturing$85,729$41
5Sales$73,669$35
6Finance$68,452$33
7Administrative$44,609$21
8Customer Service$37,425$18

How much does American Family Insurance pay by state

American Family Insurance pays the highest salaries in Massachusetts ($61,139), New York ($60,709), Washington ($57,275), Illinois ($52,086), and Wisconsin ($51,755).

New York is the #2 highest paid state at American Family Insurance.

Highest paying states at American Family Insurance

RankStateAverage American Family Insurance salaryHourly pay
1Massachusetts$61,139$29
2New York$60,709$29
3Washington$57,275$28
4Illinois$52,086$25
5Wisconsin$51,755$25

American Family Insurance competitors salaries in New York

The highest paying American Family Insurance competitor in New York is Legg Mason. The average salary at Legg Mason in New York is $196,602. The lowest paying American Family Insurance competitor in New York is Elevance Health.
RankCompany nameAverage pay in New YorkHourly pay
1Legg Mason$94,479$45
2Citi$86,956$42
3Piper Jaffray$85,079$41
4Mutual of Omaha$74,804$36
5BCS Financial$74,484$36
6Prudential Retirement Insurance And Annuity Co$70,685$34
7Liberty Northwest Insurance Corp$68,617$33
8Jackson$67,264$32
9Liberty Mutual Insurance$66,762$32
10Elevance Health$64,448$31

Recently added American Family Insurance salaries in New York

JobLocationDate addedSalary
AdviserNew York, NY04/24/2025$128,000
Property Claims AdjusterNew York, NY02/27/2025$86,000
Staff CounselNew York, NY01/26/2025$109,000

Frequently asked questions about American Family Insurance pay in New York

Search for jobs