Post job

Employee reviews

3/5

Out of 19 Casey's reviews, 26% were positive.

5 stars

4 stars

3 stars

2 stars

1 star

Based on 19 ratings

Overall rating
3.0
Work environment
2.4
Management
1.9
Career opportunities
1.8
Diversity and inclusion
3.7
Salary and benefits
2.2
Work at Casey's?
Share your experience

Casey's reviews

Employee reviews
profile
4.0
A zippia user wrote a review on Jul 2024
Pros of working at Casey's

Stable income, internal career advancement opportunities, retail experience, customer service experience, close relationships to coworkers, and active leadership assistance.

Cons of working at Casey's

Physically taxing at times, can be slow paced some days, corporate leadership tends to make changes that can cause trouble with customers often, little security, and store hours given for total pay to employees is capped, making pay raises nearly impossible, or interfering with who is scheduled when.

Casey's benefits

Half off discount on all made in kitchen foods, with free drinks while you're clocked in.

What do you like best about Casey's's CEO and the leadership team?

They actively go to stores, and meet with employees, including managers of all levels, to personally meet members of the team, emphasize changes that can/will happen to improve the store, and give/recieve feedback on how the store is faring for future decisions.

How would you improve Casey's's culture?

Focusing more on paying liveable wages to employees depending on the pricing of the region, and success of the store, versus capping the store pay limit, and forcing managers to divide everything across every employee. Benefits for employees when working while injured, or disabled when part time would help too. I personally saw no benefits specifically because it wasn't legally required as a part time employee.

How did you prepare for the Casey's interview?

I prepared for my interview by emphasizing my personality, work ethic, wanting to work for the company to help my community, and commitment to professionalism while on the clock.

How does your compensation at Casey's compare to the industry average?

My compensation only rose $2.25 from $12/h to $14.25/h after 5 years, with one $1 raise 2 weeks in, and one bonus of $1.25 for working through COVID. That compared to the average of between $12 starting and $16 some of my coworkers were at in the same position.

What's the diversity at Casey's like?

You can find just about anybody working at Casey's. They don't discriminate against race, religion, ethnicity, disability, both mental and physical, or age, as long as you're the appropriate minimum age for the position.

What brings you the most joy at Casey's?

The most fulfilling thing working there for me was the people. You learn who the regulars are, and you work with your coworkers enough to consider them related to you in some way after a while.

Is this useful?
profile
3.0
A zippia user wrote a review on Mar 2024
Pros of working at Casey's

Close to home,like the pizza. Wage is good.

Cons of working at Casey's

Never enough staff,management not trained properly,no accountability for management just delegating their responsibility to everyone else so they can leave early or smoke for half of there shift.outdated equipment pumps are old .run more like Dollar General.

Casey's benefits

Really don't have any wxcept close to home.

How would you improve Casey's's culture?

Stop changing everything and

What do you like best about Casey's's CEO and the leadership team?

It use to be better work environment loved my job before all the changes we were a team with well trained management. And they worked hard.

How did you prepare for the Casey's interview?

Resume and brought my experience and work ethic.

How does your compensation at Casey's compare to the industry average?

I feel Caseypay in my area is good ,but could have better perks.

What brings you the most joy at Casey's?

The customer are the best part of my job ,they are more patient knowing we don't have adequate staff.

What's the diversity at Casey's like?

I feel that Casey's could do better but small town it's hard to compare with bigger towns.

Is this useful?
profile
3.0
A zippia user wrote a review on Mar 2024
Pros of working at Casey's

Work environment, meeting relatives I don't get to see, work most holidays, so I don't get to share the holidays,

Cons of working at Casey's

Lack of pay, percentage only, hard to get vacation, cause lack of help, lot of overtime, people on different shifts not working together,

Casey's benefits

None

What do you like best about Casey's's CEO and the leadership team?

I try to keep a safe and clean environment for my customers, and have the store stocked, cups, napkins ect

How would you improve Casey's's culture?

I'm proving wages, to attract people, to work, to maintain, and be the best store, which most customers visit,

How did you prepare for the Casey's interview?

Clean and neat, presentable,

How does your compensation at Casey's compare to the industry average?

Below

What's the diversity at Casey's like?

Ok

What brings you the most joy at Casey's?

My family has been in the community for over 300 years, so I know most people, lot of them are business owners, so I see family members.on most days, and meet new ones

Is this useful?
profile
3.0
A zippia user wrote a review on Oct 2024
Pros of working at Casey's

Customers and district manager. N

Cons of working at Casey's

the manager that is an alcoholic was terrible to work with. Always coming in late and always had a rude attitude with everyone.

Casey's benefits

Having great coworkers to work with

What do you like best about Casey's's CEO and the leadership team?

Leadership was bad but CEO wouldn't listen and he understood when I had to quit

How would you improve Casey's's culture?

Better management to keep the store cleaned up like it's supposed to be.

How did you prepare for the Casey's interview?

They didn't interview me but usually I get the paperwork that you would need put together and make sure I look decent/professional in front of you

Is this useful?
profile
3.0
A zippia user wrote a review on Oct 2023
Pros of working at Casey's

I like the customers,they are brand loyal

Cons of working at Casey's

Mismanaged, no advancement for qualified candidates. Do not promote from within qualified candidates, but do hire outside for jobs that current employees have applied . Will promote those with drug charges, living in rehab, no vehicle, 3 months on job over those with degrees,solid management references and experience,and clean records.

Casey's benefits

Free coffee

Is this useful?
profile
3.0
A zippia user wrote a review on Mar 2024
Pros of working at Casey's

Work environment, meeting relatives I don't get to see, work most holidays, so I don't get to share the holidays,

Cons of working at Casey's

Lack of pay, percentage only, hard to get vacation, cause lack of help, lot of overtime, people on different shifts not working together,

Casey's benefits

None

What do you like best about Casey's's CEO and the leadership team?

I try to keep a safe and clean environment for my customers, and have the store stocked, cups, napkins ect

How would you improve Casey's's culture?

I'm proving wages, to attract people, to work, to maintain, and be the best store, which most customers visit,

How did you prepare for the Casey's interview?

Clean and neat, presentable,

How does your compensation at Casey's compare to the industry average?

Below

What's the diversity at Casey's like?

Ok

What brings you the most joy at Casey's?

My family has been in the community for over 300 years, so I know most people, lot of them are business owners, so I see family members.on most days, and meet new ones

Is this useful?
profile
2.0
A zippia user wrote a review on Jul 2023
Pros of working at Casey's

The main thing I liked about the job was the convenience of location

Cons of working at Casey's

management, work hours and staffing were bad

Is this useful?
profile
4.0
A zippia user wrote a review on Jun 2023
Pros of working at Casey's

It is a medium pace job, not too slow but not too fast either. Customers and employees are generally easy to work with.

Cons of working at Casey's

The pay is too little for me to live off of.

Casey's benefits

Free drinks while on the clock, as well as 50% off food.

Is this useful?
profile
2.0
A zippia user wrote a review on Apr 2023
Cons of working at Casey's

Work schedules are often not posted until the day before. Working on Saturday afternoon and still not knowing what time I work the next day

Pros of working at Casey's

Nice coworkers

Is this useful?
profile
3.0
A zippia user wrote a review on May 2022
Pros of working at Casey's

I like being a valued member of a team.

Cons of working at Casey's

The management. There is no management at many stores.

Casey's benefits

All the Casey's pizza I can eat.

Is this useful?
profile
3.0
A zippia user wrote a review on Sep 2021
Pros of working at Casey's

Working with the store team a d the customers I meet

Cons of working at Casey's

The Corporation takes advantage of their long term employees. They don't pay enough for the work you put in. Instead of saying thank you they just expect more from. Store managers get paid for 45 hours a week but you have to work more so the store runs smoothly etc..

Casey's benefits

Perk is nothing

Is this useful?
profile
5.0
A zippia user wrote a review on Jun 2021
Pros of working at Casey's

Customer Service, Good hours, and working with a team.

Cons of working at Casey's

Cooking

Casey's benefits

A raise every year, working with the public.

Is this useful?
profile
2.0
A zippia user wrote a review on Apr 2021
Pros of working at Casey's

I love the customers that come in and I have got to know

Cons of working at Casey's

I don't like that the store manager is rude and has never liked me

Is this useful?
profile
5.0
A zippia user wrote a review on Aug 2020
Pros of working at Casey's

I like working for Casey’s, I just wAnt to move to North Carolina to be closer to family

Cons of working at Casey's

Need a Casey’s in the North Carolina area

Is this useful?
profile
2.0
A zippia user wrote a review on May 2020
Pros of working at Casey's

Meet new people every day

Cons of working at Casey's

Corporate not taking the employees into account

Casey's benefits

None

Is this useful?
profile
3.0
A zippia user wrote a review on Mar 2020
Pros of working at Casey's

The store managers are awesome

Cons of working at Casey's

Area supervisors and district managers need to know how to talk to store management and the workers

Casey's benefits

The benefits

Is this useful?
profile
5.0
A zippia user wrote a review on Jan 2020
Pros of working at Casey's

The management is amazing

Cons of working at Casey's

Literally everything else I swore I wouldn’t work with food ever again yet here I am. I fully believe in being happy with what your doing.

Casey's benefits

Management works with my schedule. Due to me having 3kids

Is this useful?
profile
1.0
A zippia user wrote a review on Aug 2018
Pros of working at Casey's

I like that I get to see many different faces throughout the shift.

Cons of working at Casey's

I do not like how management doesn't get reprimanded for their bad managerial skills. They get away with anything.

Casey's benefits

There is no perk or benefit unless you actually get FULL TIME like you were promised, otherwise, nothing.

Is this useful?

Rate the responsiveness of Casey's to employee reviews.

Zippia waving zebra
Work at Casey's? Share your experience

Zippia score

Casey's salaries

8.9
Salary score
The national average salary for a Casey's employee in the United States is $29,142 per year or $14 per hour. Employees in the top 10 percent can make over $41,000 per year, while employees at the bottom 10 percent earn less than $20,000 per year.

Casey's demographics summary

9.8
Diversity score
We calculated the diversity score of companies by measuring multiple factors, including the ethnic background, gender identity, and language skills of their workforce

Casey's financial performance

9.9
Performance score
We calculated the performance score of companies by measuring multiple factors, including revenue, longevity, and stock market performance.

Do you work at Casey's?

Did the Casey's act on employee feedback?