56 Best Insurance Companies To Work For In Ohio

We hand-curated a list of the best companies to work for headquartered in and around Ohio using data on salaries, company financial health, and employee diversity.

Best Companies To Work For In Ohio

Zippia Score 4.8

Company Description:

Medical Mutual of Ohio is an American mutual health insurance company. It is the oldest and largest health insurance company based in Cleveland, Ohio, and serves more than 1.6 million customers. Employing 2,500 people, Medical Mutual is one of the biggest employers in downtown Cleveland.

Show More
  • Learn More About Medical Mutual of Ohio:
  • Overview
  • Salaries
  • Jobs

Zippia Score 4.8

Company Highlights:

Established in 1935 as a car insurance company, today Grange Insurance offers affordable and customizable auto, home, life and business insurance products. It sells its products through independent agents to customers across 13 states. Grange offers options that are customized for every customer needs and its independent agents ensure excellent customer service.

Show More

Zippia Score 4.7

Company Highlights:

Nationwide started as a small mutual auto insurance company in 1925. Today, it is a Fortune 100 company that offers a full range of insurance and financial services across the country such as car, motorcycle, homeowners, pet, farm, life and commercial insurance. It also provides annuities, mutual funds, retirement plans and specialty health services.

Show More
What people like about Nationwide Mutual Insurance ...:

Freedom and compensation. Relationships I have with my clients

  • Learn More About Nationwide Mutual Insurance ...:
  • Overview
  • Reviews
  • Salaries
  • Jobs

Zippia Score 4.7

Company Highlights:

Founded in 1872 in Cincinnati, OH, Great American Insurance Group is engaged primarily in property and casualty insurance and annuity operations, focusing on specialty commercial products for businesses and individuals. It also provides risk management and surety insurance products to lenders, banks, construction contractors, and vehicle leasers. For nearly 150 years, numerous clients have trusted Great American Insurance Group to protect them.

Show More
  • Learn More About Great American Insurance Company:
  • Overview
  • Salaries
  • Jobs

Zippia Score 4.7

Company Description:

CBIZ, Inc. (CBIZ) is engaged in the professional services business. The Company operates its professional services business through acquiring and integrating accounting and financial service providers, group health benefits consulting firms, property a...

Show More
Job type you want
Full Time
Part Time
Internship
Temporary

Zippia Score 4.6

Company Description:

American Modern Insurance Group, Inc., operating under the American Modern insurance brand, is the holding company for a number of subsidiary property and casualty insurance companies that provide ...

Show More
  • Learn More About American Modern Insurance Group:
  • Overview
  • Jobs

Zippia Score 4.6

Company Description:

Safe Auto Insurance Company is a property and casualty auto insurance carrier. It is a privately held carrier and provider of state-minimum private-passenger auto insurance for drivers in the nonstandard ...

Show More
  • Learn More About Safe Auto Insurance Group:
  • Overview
  • Salaries
  • Jobs

Zippia Score 4.5

Company Highlights:

Western & Southern Financial Group (Western & Southern), a Fortune 500 company, is the parent company to a group of diversified financial services businesses that provide an array of life insurance, investments and retirement solutions. Its mission is to be a highly respected, world-class (and best in class) diversified financial services organization. The company was founded in 1888 and is based in Cincinnati, OH.

Show More
  • Learn More About Western & Southern Financial Group:
  • Overview
  • Jobs

Zippia Score 4.5

Company Description:

Learn More About What Paramount Has to Offer Members Employers Brokers Providers Individuals and Families Medicaid Medicare Dental Plans Through Your

  • Learn More About Paramount Care:
  • Overview
  • Salaries

Zippia Score 4.5

Company Description:

The Progressive Corporation is an American insurance company. It is one of the largest providers of car insurance in America. The company insures motorcycles, boats, RVs and commercial vehicles, and provides home insurance through select companies.

Show More
What people like about Progressive:

True to the Core Values in everything, superb tenure of employees, really competitive benefits.

Zippia Score 4.5

Company Description:

Aon Risk Services Northeast, Inc. (Ohio) provides retail insurance brokerage and risk management services. The company offers alternative risk financing, comprehensive insurance, insurance program design, loss control consulting, risk identification and assessment, risk management, and brokerage services. It serves governmental, private, and public organizations. The company is based in Cleveland, Ohio. Aon Risk Services Northeast, Inc. (Ohio) operates as a subsidiary of Aon plc.

Show More
  • Learn More About Aon Risk Services:
  • Overview
  • Salaries

Zippia Score 4.4

Company Description:

The Cincinnati Insurance Companies strive to be Everything Insurance Should Be by offering insurance solutions for businesses and individuals through local independent agents. With a wide range of products and services, you are sure to find answer...

Show More

Zippia Score 4.3

Company Highlights:

Ohio National Financial Services markets a variety of insurance and financial products in all states (except New York), the District of Columbia and Puerto Rico. Established in 1909, the company has grown to nearly 1,000 associates, approximately 900 of whom work at corporate headquarters in Cincinnati, OH. Its mission is to help clients achieve financial security and independence today and for future generations.

Show More
  • Learn More About Ohio National Financial Services:
  • Overview
  • Salaries
  • Jobs

Zippia Score 4.3

Company Description:

In 1921, State Automobile Mutual Insurance Company was founded. With three employees and a rented room in downtown Columbus, Ohio, Bob Pein set forth to tackle the inequities in the insurance industry. From the very beginning, State Auto advocated the ...

Show More
  • Learn More About State Auto Insurance Companies:
  • Overview
  • Salaries
  • Jobs

Zippia Score 4.3

Company Description:

Established in 1989, National Interstate is one of the leading specialty property and casualty insurance companies in the country. We offer more than 30 different insurance products, including traditional insurance, innovative alternative risk transfer...

Show More

Zippia Score 4.2

  • Learn More About First Title Agency:
  • Overview

Zippia Score 4.2

Company Description:

CompManagement is a leading provider of claims administration services for Ohio employers.

  • Learn More About CompManagement:
  • Overview

Zippia Score 4.2

Company Description:

Progressive Automotive in Ohio offers custom hot rod frames & chassis for sale for Ford, Chevy and many other types of makes and models. Click here to browse our inventory and services, or contact us to learn more information today at 740-862-4696.

Show More
  • Learn More About Progressive Automotive:
  • Overview

Zippia Score 4.1

Company Description:

Central Insurance offers quality, affordable insurance coverages for your home, auto, and business. We are a Trusted Choice company operating exclusively through independent agents.

Show More
  • Learn More About Central Insurance Companies:
  • Overview

Zippia Score 4.1

  • Learn More About Dawson Companies:
  • Overview
  • Salaries

Zippia Score 4.1

Company Description:

KOI Auto Parts is an American chain of auto parts stores founded in 1946 in Newport, Kentucky. Today KOI Auto Parts operates more than 70 stores located throughout the US states Ohio, Kentucky, and Indiana. The corporate headquarters of KOI Auto Parts is located in Cincinnati, Ohio.

Show More
  • Learn More About KOI Auto Parts:
  • Overview

Zippia Score 4.1

Company Highlights:

Founded in 1947, Safelite AutoGlass is the largest auto glass specialist company in the United States with more than 720 locations nationwide. It specializes in windshield fixing. Whatever glass needs customers have, they can have their auto glass replaced or repaired by Safelite specialists. Some of the company's advantages include innovative technology, caring customer service, eco-friendly initiatives, customer-focused culture, and much more.

Show More

Zippia Score 4.1

  • Learn More About Argus International:
  • Overview

Zippia Score 4.0

Company Description:

Fraternal Order of Eagles is an international fraternal organization that was founded on February 6, 1898, in Seattle, Washington, by a group of six theater owners including John Cort, brothers John W. and Tim J. Considine, Harry Leavitt, Mose Goldsmith and Arthur Williams.

Show More
  • Learn More About Fraternal Order of Eagles:
  • Overview

Zippia Score 4.0

Company Description:

A full service EMS with combined benefits found in both large and small companies. We offer the technical capabilities, financial resources, and customized supply chain management programs typically found with larger EMS companies, along with the agili...

Show More
  • Learn More About Dynalab:
  • Overview

Zippia Score 4.0

  • Learn More About American Select Insurance Co:
  • Overview

Zippia Score 4.0

  • Learn More About Ohio Printing Co:
  • Overview

Zippia Score 4.0

Company Description:

An InForce Policy Management Platform leveraging technology to simplify the complexities of life insurance management. #LifeInsurance #InsurTech

  • Learn More About Proformex:
  • Overview

Zippia Score 4.0

Company Description:

With $91.2 billion in assets, OPERS is the largest public pension fund in Ohio and the 11th-largest public pension fund in the United States. OPERS provides retirement, disability and survivor benefits for more than 1 million public employees.

Show More

Zippia Score 4.0

Company Highlights:

Hylant is one of the largest privately held insurance brokerage firms in the US Hylant offers complete risk management services, employee benefits consultation, wellness strategies, loss control, healthcare management and a wide array of insurance solutions for both businesses and individuals. The company has 14 offices in Ohio, Michigan, Illinois, Indiana, Florida and Tennessee with more than 650 professionals on staff.

Show More
  • Learn More About Hylant:
  • Overview

Zippia Score 3.9

Company Description:

Health Design Plus is an innovative 3rd party administrator & population health management company for self-funded employers of all sizes. Call us today!

  • Learn More About Health Design Plus:
  • Overview
  • Jobs

Zippia Score 3.9

Company Description:

Alveo specializes in aggregating claims and accelerating the remittance of reimbursement to the billing providers/physicians.

Zippia Score 3.9

Company Description:

Voluntary benefits legal plans information

  • Learn More About Hyatt Legal Plans:
  • Overview

Zippia Score 3.9

Company Highlights:

Flagel Huber Flagel employs more than 30 certified public accountants (CPAs) with more than 600 years of combined experience. This expertise, combined with their staunch reputation and a team of reliable professionals committed to the highest standards of excellence, has been the cornerstone in building and sustaining long-lasting client relationships. Additionally, this firm continually strives to recruit the best and brightest minds to their ranks, bringing with them an enthusiastic commitment to the profession and a modern perspective on current trends.

Show More
  • Learn More About Flagel Huber Flagel:
  • Overview

Zippia Score 3.9

Company Description:

Althans Insurance is a full service agency representing approximately 50 different insurance companies to handle your business, franchise & personal needs.

  • Learn More About Althans Insurance Agency:
  • Overview

Zippia Score 3.8

Company Description:

Stolly Insurance Group is committed to providing outstanding insurance protection to our clients while delivering superior customer service.

  • Learn More About Stolly Insurance:
  • Overview

Zippia Score 3.8

Company Description:

QuickInsured covering all of your personal and business needs. Our convenient website allows you to request insurance quotes twenty-four hours a day. Our valued customers can also service their policies at anytime, day or night, at www.quickinsured.com.

Show More
  • Learn More About QuickInsured:
  • Overview

Zippia Score 3.8

Company Description:

HCF was formed in 1932 to provide health insurance cover to Australians. Since then, it has grown to become one of the country's largest combined registered private health fund and life insurance organisations.

Show More
  • Learn More About HCF Management:
  • Overview
  • Salaries

Zippia Score 3.7

Company Description:

Cornell Abraxas Group, Inc. provides rehabilitation services. The company was incorporated in 1997 and is based in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. Cornell Abraxas Group, Inc. operates as a subsidiary of Cornell Corrections Management, LLC.

Show More
  • Learn More About Cornell Abraxas Group:
  • Overview

Zippia Score 3.7

Company Description:

The benefits small businesses can avail when getting loans from the lenders in New Zealand to support their initial growth.

  • Learn More About West Point Market:
  • Overview

Zippia Score 3.7

  • Learn More About Kramer Graphics:
  • Overview

Zippia Score 3.7

  • Learn More About Columbus Life Insurance Company:
  • Overview

Zippia Score 3.7

  • Learn More About Citadel Insurance Associates:
  • Overview

Zippia Score 3.6

Company Description:

Magazine Printer, Catalog Printer, Direct Mail - Finishing, Mailing, Distribution

  • Learn More About Freeport Press:
  • Overview

Zippia Score 3.6

Company Highlights:

First Mutual Holdings Limited is a financial services group in Zimbabwe that focuses on short term insurance; short term re-insurance; life assurance; long term re-insurance; as well as the property sector. The company emphasizes recruitment, training and retention of quality skills, and harnessing information technology platforms. Its mission is to provides accessible solutions that enrich the lives of all households, communities and businesses by managing risk, creating and managing wealth.

Show More
  • Learn More About First Mutual Holdings:
  • Overview

Zippia Score 3.5

  • Learn More About Landsel Title Agency:
  • Overview

Zippia Score 3.5

Company Description:

Zito Insurance offers insurance products and risk management services for individuals and businesses. Offices are located in Mentor, Ohio and Rocky River, Ohio.

Show More
  • Learn More About Zito Insurance Agency:
  • Overview

Zippia Score 3.4

Company Description:

MarshBerry's seasoned professionals and experience can provide tremendous value for virtually any buyer or seller in the insurance distribution market.

  • Learn More About MarshBerry:
  • Overview

Zippia Score 3.3

Company Description:

Since 1921, Paige & Byrnes Insurance has been family owned and focused on serving the insurance needs of our clients throughout Ohio.

  • Learn More About Paige & Byrnes Insurance:
  • Overview

Zippia Score 3.3

Company Description:

Insurance & Surety Bonds on L. Calvin Jones

  • Learn More About L. Calvin Jones & Co.:
  • Overview
  • Salaries

Zippia Score 3.3

Company Description:

Personal and Commercial Lines of Insurance Based On Your Needs. Offices in Wilmington, Chillicothe, Cincinnati, Delaware & Springboro. #ProtectYourAssets

  • Learn More About SFM Insurance:
  • Overview

Zippia Score 3.3

Company Description:

Schauer Group is the risk management, insurance and human capital services team that delivers because we serve as an extension of your leadership team.

What people like about Schauer Independent Insurance Services:

Growth culture, benefits, people I with & support of management team.

  • Learn More About Schauer Independent Insurance Services:
  • Overview
  • Reviews

Zippia Score 3.2

Company Description:

A leader in employee health benefits management, including third party administration and worksite wellness.

  • Learn More About MedBen:
  • Overview

Zippia Score 3.1

Company Description:

Central Travel - We specialize in cruises, luxury vacations, honeymoons, Disney destinations, corporate travel and more! Call our Ohio-based Travel Agents today

Show More
  • Learn More About Central Travel:
  • Overview

Zippia Score 3.1

Company Mission Statement:

Our mission is to be a high-performing organization that is recognized as a long-term, profitable, premier insurance company by agents, policyholders, employees, the industry, and our local community.

Show More
  • Learn More About Celina Insurance Group:
  • Overview

Zippia Score 2.9

  • Learn More About Albert Screenprint:
  • Overview

Best Companies In Ohio

RankCompanyZippia Score
1Medical Mutual of Ohio4.8
2Grange Insurance4.8
3Nationwide Mutual Insurance ...4.7
4Great American Insurance Company4.7
5CBIZ, Inc.4.7
6American Modern Insurance Group4.6
7Safe Auto Insurance Group4.6
8Western & Southern Financial Group4.5
9Paramount Care4.5
10Progressive4.5
11Aon Risk Services4.5
12Cincinnati Financial4.4
13Ohio National Financial Services4.3
14State Auto Insurance Companies4.3
15National Interstate4.3
16First Title Agency4.2
17CompManagement4.2
18Progressive Automotive4.2
19Central Insurance Companies4.1
20Dawson Companies4.1
21KOI Auto Parts4.1
22Safelite AutoGlass4.1
23Argus International4.1
24Fraternal Order of Eagles4.0
25Dynalab4.0
26American Select Insurance Co4.0
27Ohio Printing Co4.0
28Proformex4.0
29OPERS4.0
30Hylant4.0
31Health Design Plus3.9
32ECP3.9
33Hyatt Legal Plans3.9
34Flagel Huber Flagel3.9
35Althans Insurance Agency3.9
36Stolly Insurance3.8
37QuickInsured3.8
38HCF Management3.8
39Cornell Abraxas Group3.7
40West Point Market3.7
41Kramer Graphics3.7
42Columbus Life Insurance Company3.7
43Citadel Insurance Associates3.7
44Freeport Press3.6
45First Mutual Holdings3.6
46Landsel Title Agency3.5
47Zito Insurance Agency3.5
48MarshBerry3.4
49Paige & Byrnes Insurance3.3
50L. Calvin Jones & Co.3.3
51SFM Insurance3.3
52Schauer Independent Insurance Services3.3
53MedBen3.2
54Central Travel3.1
55Celina Insurance Group3.1
56Albert Screenprint2.9
0 selections