Post job

Cottingham & Butler main competitors are Esurance, Boston Mutual Life Insurance, and Church Mutual Insurance.

Competitor Summary. See how Cottingham & Butler compares to its main competitors:

  • Esurance has the most employees (3,000).
  • Employees at Esurance earn more than most of the competitors, with an average yearly salary of $66,733.
Work at Cottingham & Butler?
Share your experience

Cottingham & Butler vs competitors

CompanyFounding dateZippia scoreHeadquarters# of LocationsRevenueEmployees
1887
4.4
Dubuque, IA1$2.3B3,000
1958
3.7
Denver, CO1$12.0M100
1980
4.4
Aurora, CO1$478.0M500
1897
4.2
Merrill, WI1$770.0M750
-
3.8
Tulare, CA1$3.5M52
1902
4.6
Charlotte, NC1$110.0M720
1998
4.8
San Francisco, CA4$1.0B3,000
1920
3.8
Franklin, PA3$5.4M50
Member Insurance Agency, Inc
-
4.0
Barrington, IL1$5.2M5
1891
4.0
Canton, MA2$274.2M200
Rogers Benefit Group
-
4.1
Dallas, TX1$1.0M10
1988
4.6
Montgomery, AL1$47.0M50
1954
4.2
Concord, NH1$150.0M249
2009
4.3
Glen Allen, VA1$529.0M750
2008
4.3
Deerfield Beach, FL170$420.0M350
2013
4.2
Reading, PA1$17.0M175
1864
4.6
Poughkeepsie, NY15$90.8M200
1914
4.4
Colorado Springs, CO7$170.0M249
-
3.6
Chula Vista, CA1$3.3M33
1900
4.1
Walnut Creek, CA2$1.3B1,727
1949
3.9
Menasha, WI1$40.2M100

Rate how well Cottingham & Butler differentiates itself from its competitors.

Zippia waving zebra

Cottingham & Butler salaries vs competitors

Among Cottingham & Butler competitors, employees at Esurance earn the most with an average yearly salary of $66,733.

Compare Cottingham & Butler salaries vs competitors

CompanyAverage salaryHourly salarySalary score
Cottingham & Butler
$43,528$20.93-
Delta Dental of Colorado
$53,306$25.63-
2-10
$46,713$22.46-
Church Mutual Insurance
$54,357$26.13-
Walter Mortensen Insurance
$41,066$19.74-
AAA Carolinas
$36,537$17.57-

Compare Cottingham & Butler job title salaries vs competitors

CompanyHighest salaryHourly salary
Cottingham & Butler
$76,290$36.68
Esurance
$86,668$41.67
Church Mutual Insurance
$77,639$37.33
Boston Mutual Life Insurance
$77,360$37.19
National Brokers of America
$76,748$36.90
AAA Northern California, Nevada & Utah
$76,573$36.81
Elephant Insurance
$75,837$36.46
California Casualty
$75,728$36.41
Delta Dental of Colorado
$75,511$36.30
Davis & Towle Insurance Group
$74,823$35.97
2-10
$74,756$35.94
Rogers Benefit Group
$73,633$35.40
Alliance Insurance Group
$64,552$31.03
People's Trust Insurance
$64,074$30.80
McClone
$61,919$29.77
AAA Carolinas
$49,800$23.94
Franklin Insurance Agency
$49,430$23.76
Member Insurance Agency, Inc
$47,652$22.91
Marshall & Sterling
$46,862$22.53
South Bay Health & Insurance Services (sbhis)
$46,167$22.20

Do you work at Cottingham & Butler?

Is Cottingham & Butler able to compete effectively with similar companies?

Cottingham & Butler jobs

Cottingham & Butler demographics vs competitors

Compare gender at Cottingham & Butler vs competitors

Job titleMaleFemale
Boston Mutual Life Insurance30%70%
Delta Dental of Colorado38%63%
California Casualty42%58%
Church Mutual Insurance44%56%
Franklin Insurance Agency55%45%
Cottingham & Butler--

Compare race at Cottingham & Butler vs competitors

CompanyWhiteHispanic or LatinoBlack or African AmericanAsianUnknownDiversity score
75%7%9%7%3%
7.0
66%15%6%8%5%
8.0
68%11%8%11%2%
6.9
65%13%12%6%3%
8.0
70%15%6%5%4%
7.0

Cottingham & Butler and similar companies CEOs

CEOBio

Michael A. Hetke
AAA Carolinas

Richard V. Poirier
Church Mutual Insurance

Richard Poirier is a VP:Claims at Church Mutual, Board Member at Church Mutual, and President/CEO at Church Mutual and is based in Merrill, Wisconsin. He has worked as Senior Vice President Claims, Agency Markets at Liberty Mutual; Chief Operating Officer at Church Mutual; and Division Senior Vice President- Western Division at Wausau Insurance. Richard studied at North Branford High School between 1974 and 1979; Marquette University, BA 1983 between 1979 and 1983; and Marquette University between 1983 and 1986.

Jonathan Adkisson
Esurance

Jonathan Adkisson is a seasoned insurance executive with a passion for delivering results through an obsessive focus on the customer, relentless pursuit of cost efficiencies, and a servant-leadership style that brings the best from his team. As president of Esurance from 2015 to 2020, he led the profitability turnaround while continuing the impressive growth of Allstate’s $2 billion stand-alone subsidiary. In 2020, Jonathan became General Manager of Allstate Direct, as Allstate shifted to use the Esurance people and capabilities to drive even stronger growth in the direct channel by leveraging the Allstate brand.

George Schaeffer
People's Trust Insurance

Robert Nicolay (Bob)
California Casualty

Paul Quaranto is a Chairman/President at LIFE INSURANCE CO OF BOSTON and is based in Canton, Massachusetts. He has worked as Vice President, Group Insurance at Boston Mutual Life Insur Co; President and Chief Operating Officer at Boston Mutual Life Insur Co; and Group Sales Manager at Boston Mutual Life Insur Co. Paul attended LOMA between 2011 and 2011, Colby College between 1976 and 1980, and Anna Maria College between 2011 and 2011.

Alberto Schiavon
Elephant Insurance

Cottingham & Butler competitors FAQs

Search for jobs