Post job

Cottingham & Butler salary estimate

$43,528yearly

$20.93 hourly rate

Entry-level salary
$23,000 yearly salary
Updated December 15, 2025

Cottingham & Butler Salary Overview

The average salary at Cottingham & Butler is approximately $43,528 annually, reflecting a commitment to competitive pay. Salaries may vary based on specific roles, locations, and departments within the company. For instance, positions in management typically offer higher compensation compared to entry-level roles. Additionally, salaries are influenced by geographic location, with some areas presenting more lucrative opportunities.

Understanding how compensation is structured can assist potential employees in making informed career choices. Exploring the highest-paying jobs, such as those in customer service and management, reveals valuable insights into the company's pay scale. By recognizing these factors, job seekers can better evaluate their options and align their career aspirations with Cottingham & Butler's offerings.

Highest paying jobs at Cottingham & Butler

The highest paying jobs at Cottingham & Butler are vice president & general manager, division manager, health director, and registered nurse. Vice president & general manager jobs at Cottingham & Butler earn an average yearly salary of $157,038, Cottingham & Butler division manager jobs average $128,622, and Cottingham & Butler health director jobs average $82,952.

The lowest paying Cottingham & Butler roles include marketing internship and service assistant. Cottingham & Butler marketing internship average salary is $30,648 per year. So while the average Cottingham & Butler salary is $43,528 there is a big variation in pay depending on the role.

Highest paying jobs at Cottingham & Butler

RankJob titleAverage Cottingham & Butler salaryHourly rate
1Vice President & General Manager$157,038$75.50
2Division Manager$128,622$61.84
3Health Director$82,952$39.88
4Registered Nurse$80,872$38.88
5First Officer$80,305$38.61
6Accounting Supervisor$79,051$38.01
7Account Executive$76,290$36.68
8Business Analyst$67,033$32.23
9Finance Analyst$65,565$31.52
10Safety Consultant$63,362$30.46
11Insurance Broker$55,544$26.70
12Marketing Specialist$53,906$25.92
13Auto Claims Adjuster$46,824$22.51
14Benefit Specialist$45,672$21.96
15Insurance Sales Agent$44,516$21.40
16Health Coach$43,968$21.14
17Medical Claims Examiner$43,603$20.96
18Coordinator$42,854$20.60
19Bookkeeper$41,699$20.05
20Accounting Clerk$38,848$18.68

Rate the fairness of Cottingham & Butler's compensation policies.

Zippia waving zebra

How much does Cottingham & Butler pay by location?

The average Cottingham & Butler salary varies by location. Cottingham & Butler salaries are the highest in Appleton, WI, at $44,563 per year. Cottingham & Butler pays the second highest average salary in Pittsburgh, PA, at $43,375 per year. It's important to factor in the cost of living when negotiating a salary or choosing a place to work.

Highest paying Cottingham & Butler locations

RankLocationAverage Cottingham & Butler salaryHourly rate
1Appleton, WI$44,563$21.42
2Pittsburgh, PA$43,375$20.85
3Davenport, IA$41,459$19.93

Do you work at Cottingham & Butler?

Were you satisfied with Cottingham & Butler's salary and benefits?

Cottingham & Butler salaries by department

Salaries at Cottingham & Butler vary depending on the department you work in. Cottingham & Butler salaries in the healthcare department are the highest with an average salary of $75,895. Employees in the sales department at Cottingham & Butler receive relatively high salaries as well, with an average salary of $51,403 per year. Departments that don't pay as well at Cottingham & Butler include the customer service and the administrative organizational functions, with employees earning average salaries of $34,238 and $39,591, respectively.

Average Cottingham & Butler salary by department

RankDepartmentAverage Cottingham & Butler salaryHourly rate
1Healthcare$75,895$36.49
2Sales$51,403$24.71
3Accounting$49,109$23.61
4Finance$47,913$23.04
5Marketing$45,358$21.81
6Human Resources$43,857$21.09
7Education$41,891$20.14
8Administrative$39,592$19.03
9Customer Service$34,239$16.46

How much does Cottingham & Butler pay by department?

Best paying Cottingham & Butler customer service salaries

RankPositionAverage Cottingham & Butler salaryHourly rate
1Service Representative$36,442$17.52
2Account Services Representative$33,471$16.09
3Service Assistant$32,216$15.49

Best paying Cottingham & Butler sales salaries

RankPositionAverage Cottingham & Butler salaryHourly rate
1Account Executive$76,290$36.68
2Insurance Broker$55,544$26.70
3Insurance Sales Agent$44,516$21.40
4Sales Internship$35,789$17.21
5Account Services Representative$33,471$16.09

Best paying Cottingham & Butler administrative salaries

RankPositionAverage Cottingham & Butler salaryHourly rate
1Bookkeeper$41,699$20.05
2Personal Assistant$39,515$19.00
3Administrative Assistant$36,276$17.44

Cottingham & Butler competitors’ average salaries

Average salaries at Cottingham & Butler competitors, like Esurance, Boston Mutual Life Insurance, and Church Mutual Insurance, vary. Esurance employees earn the highest salaries, with an average yearly salary of $66,733. The average salary at Boston Mutual Life Insurance is $60,356 per year, and the average salary at Church Mutual Insurance is $54,357 per year.

Highest paying Cottingham & Butler competitors

RankCompany nameZippia scoreAverage salary
1Esurance4.8$66,733
2Boston Mutual Life Insurance4.0$60,356
3Church Mutual Insurance4.2$54,357
4Delta Dental of Colorado3.7$53,306
5California Casualty4.4$52,505
6Elephant Insurance4.3$52,394
7National Brokers of America4.2$51,905
8People's Trust Insurance4.3$50,640
92-104.4$46,713
10Rogers Benefit Group4.1$46,380
11Alliance Insurance Group4.6$45,439
12McClone3.9$45,142
13AAA Northern California, Nevada & Utah4.1$43,351
14Franklin Insurance Agency3.8$42,741
15Member Insurance Agency, Inc4.0$42,226
16South Bay Health & Insurance Services (sbhis)3.6$41,682
17Walter Mortensen Insurance3.8$41,066
18Davis & Towle Insurance Group4.2$39,609
19Marshall & Sterling4.6$37,604
20AAA Carolinas4.6$36,537

Frequently asked questions about Cottingham & Butler salaries

Search for jobs

Zippia gives an in-depth look into the details of Cottingham & Butler, including salaries, political affiliations, employee data, and more, in order to inform job seekers about Cottingham & Butler. The employee data is based on information from people who have self-reported their past or current employments at Cottingham & Butler. The data on this page is also based on data sources collected from public and open data sources on the Internet and other locations, as well as proprietary data we licensed from other companies. Sources of data may include, but are not limited to, the BLS, company filings, estimates based on those filings, H1B filings, and other public and private datasets. While we have made attempts to ensure that the information displayed are correct, Zippia is not responsible for any errors or omissions or for the results obtained from the use of this information. None of the information on this page has been provided or approved by Cottingham & Butler. The data presented on this page does not represent the view of Cottingham & Butler and its employees or that of Zippia.

Cottingham & Butler may also be known as or be related to Cottingham & Butler, Cottingham & Butler Inc and Cottingham & Butler, Inc.