Hagerty Insurance Agency Overview

Hagerty (U.S.) is a family business specialised in car and boat insurance. Our passion drives us to keep improving our product and to give our clients the best service imaginable.
The staff at Hagerty Insurance Agency come from unusually diverse demographic backgrounds. The company is 37.0% female and 31.8% ethnic minorities. Hagerty Insurance Agency employees are slightly more likely to be members of the Democratic Party than the Republican Party, with 60.0% of employees identifying as members of the Democratic Party. Despite their political differences, employees at Hagerty Insurance Agency seem to be happy. The company has great employee retention with staff members usually staying for 4.3 years. The average employee at Hagerty Insurance Agency makes $47,408 per year. In comparison, some of its highest paying competitors, like HUB International, Bankers Financial, and Horace Mann Educators, pay $61,329, $50,819, and $49,813, respectively.
Based in Michigan, Hagerty Insurance Agency is a small insurance company with only 200 employees and an annual revenue of $193.6M.

The Organization’s Mission

To build long-term relationships with our customers and clients and provide exceptional customer service, seeking business through innovation and advanced technology.







Founded in



Traverse City, MI



Organization Type


Is This Your Company?

Hagerty Insurance Agency Employee Reviews

Zippia Official Logo


Zippia UserJune 2020


Zippia Official LogoZippia UserJune 2020

What Do You Like About Working There?

Company Culture, challenging work, focus on work life balance and professional improvement

What DON'T You Like About Working There?

unqualified management

What Are Your Favorite Benefits/Perks?

Paid community service
Anonymous review of Hagerty Insurance Agency

Do you work at Hagerty Insurance Agency? Rate Hagerty Insurance Agency as an Employer.

How would you rate working at Hagerty Insurance Agency?

Work at Hagerty Insurance Agency? Share your experience anonymously.

What do you like about working for Hagerty Insurance Agency?

The Team At Hagerty Insurance Agency

  • McKeel Hagerty (CEO)
  • Frank Hagerty (Founders)
  • Louise Hagerty (Founders)

Hagerty Insurance Agency Company Rankings

Hagerty Insurance Agency is ranked #9 on the Best Insurance Companies to Work For in Michigan list. Zippia's Best Places to Work lists provide unbiased, data-based evaluations of companies. Rankings are based on government and proprietary data on salaries, company financial health, and employee diversity.

Read more about how we rank companies.

Hagerty Insurance Agency Salaries

How much does Hagerty Insurance Agency pay?
The national average salary for a Hagerty Insurance Agency employee in the United States is $47,408 per year. Employees in the top 10 percent can make over $89,000 per year, while employees at the bottom 10 percent earn less than $25,000 per year.
Salary Score
Average Employee Earnings

Hagerty Insurance Agency Salaries By Job Title

While the average employee salary at Hagerty Insurance Agency is $47,408, there is a big variation in pay depending on the role. The higher paying positions at Hagerty Insurance Agency include Underwriter, Subject Matter Expert, Director Of Human Resources, and Project Team Lead. A typical Underwriter salary at Hagerty Insurance Agency is $113,819 per year. To get a better sense of the salaries at Hagerty Insurance Agency, other roles such as Data Entry Processor and Production Worker can be considered as well. For comparison, the title Data Entry Processor at Hagerty Insurance Agency earns $25,909 per year.
Job Title
Average Salarydesc
Salary Range95k - 135k$114k$113,819
Subject Matter Expert
Salary Range105k - 119k$112k$112,216
Director Of Human Resources
Salary Range99k - 116k$107k$107,487
Project Team Lead
Salary Range92k - 105k$99k$98,953
Automation Tester
Salary Range85k - 96k$91k$90,700
Management Consultant
Salary Range78k - 95k$86k$86,358
Risk Assessment Analyst
Salary Range77k - 94k$86k$85,620
Territory Manager
Salary Range77k - 87k$82k$82,266
Finance Consultant
Salary Range73k - 91k$82k$81,758
Lead Person
Salary Range70k - 76k$73k$73,406

Jobs from similar companies

Hagerty Insurance Agency Careers

On average, employees at Hagerty Insurance Agency stay with the company for 4.3 years. Employees most commonly join Hagerty Insurance Agency after leaving Sears Holdings. When they leave Hagerty Insurance Agency, they most frequently get their next job at Caterpillar.

Top Employers After Hagerty Insurance Agency

Jobs from similar companies

Hagerty Insurance Agency Employee Demographics

Diversity Score
We calculated the diversity score of companies by measuring multiple factors, including the ethnic background, gender identity, and language skills of their workforce.

Jobs from companies you might like

Hagerty Insurance Agency Employees Education

Of the 200 employees at Hagerty Insurance Agency, 17.7% attended Northwestern Michigan College. Employees at Hagerty Insurance Agency most frequently majored in Business, and most employees’ highest level of education is a Bachelors.

Do you Work At Hagerty Insurance Agency?

Help us make this company more transparent.

Hagerty Insurance Agency Employee Political Affiliation

Hagerty Insurance Agency employees are most likely to be members of the Democratic Party. The largest donation made to a political party by a Hagerty Insurance Agency employee was by Thomas Jones. Thomas Jones donated $59,730 to the Democratic Party.

Employee Political Donations

NameJob TitlePartyDonation
Thomas JonesExecutive
ExecutiveDemocratic Party
$59,730Democratic Party
Louise HagertyAgent
AgentRepublican Party
$4,115Republican Party
Jonathan SteinWriter And Editor
Writer And EditorDemocratic Party
$1,764Democratic Party
Catherine MinsterVice President Product Development
Vice President Product DevelopmentRepublican Party
$1,752Republican Party
McKeel HagertyPresident
PresidentRepublican Party
$1,600Republican Party
Stephen HagertyPresident
PresidentDemocratic Party
$1,525Democratic Party
Cameron HillConsultant
ConsultantDemocratic Party
$1,524Democratic Party
Victor OrtegaDisaster Recovery Manager
Disaster Recovery ManagerDemocratic Party
$1,419Democratic Party
Todd SandersManager
ManagerDemocratic Party
$750Democratic Party
Adam MartinWest Coast Sales Manager
West Coast Sales ManagerRepublican Party
$750Republican Party
Show More

Hagerty Insurance Agency Financial Performance

Performance Score
We calculated the performance score of companies by measuring multiple factors, including revenue, longevity, and stock market performance.


$100M - $1B

Founded in


Organization type


How Would You Rate The Company Culture Of Hagerty Insurance Agency?

Have you worked at Hagerty Insurance Agency? Help other job seekers by rating Hagerty Insurance Agency.

Hagerty Insurance Agency Competitors

Based on our research, similar companies to Hagerty Insurance Agency are HUB International, Bankers Financial, and Horace Mann Educators. The wages at HUB International average higher than the other similar companies, where the median salary is $61,329 per year. Employees at Bankers Financial earn an average of $50,819 per year, and the employees at Horace Mann Educators earn an average salary of $49,813 per year.
Average Salarydesc
HUB International
Salary Range44k - 84k$61k$61,329
Bankers Financial
Salary Range34k - 74k$51k$50,819
Horace Mann
Salary Range34k - 71k$50k$49,813

National Insurance Services

Salary Range34k - 70k$49k$49,273

North Carolina Mutual Life Insurance

Salary Range34k - 67k$49k$48,514

Franklin Mutual Insurance

Salary Range34k - 67k$48k$48,138

American Heritage Life Insurance Company

Salary Range26k - 53k$38k$37,845

Frequently Asked Questions about Hagerty Insurance Agency

When was Hagerty Insurance Agency founded?

Hagerty Insurance Agency was founded in 1991.

How many Employees does Hagerty Insurance Agency have?

Hagerty Insurance Agency has 200 employees.

How much money does Hagerty Insurance Agency make?

Hagerty Insurance Agency generates $193.6M in revenue.

What industry is Hagerty Insurance Agency in?

Hagerty Insurance Agency is in the insurance industry.

What is Hagerty Insurance Agency's mission?

Hagerty Insurance Agency's mission statement is "To build long-term relationships with our customers and clients and provide exceptional customer service, seeking business through innovation and advanced technology."

What type of company is Hagerty Insurance Agency?

Hagerty Insurance Agency is a private company.

Who are Hagerty Insurance Agency's competitors?

Hagerty Insurance Agency competitors include North Carolina Mutual Life Insurance, Yates Insurance Agency, Babb,, New Liberty Insurance, Nameplate, The Ashley Group, Platinum Supplemental Insurance, Lyons Companies, Bmi Companies, Great Western Insurance, The AIM Group, American Heritage Life Insurance Company, HUB International, A/E Graphics,, Horace Mann Educators, Scott Insurance, Bankers Financial, Franklin Mutual Insurance, National Insurance Services, Cabrillo Coastal General Insurance Agency.

Who works at Hagerty Insurance Agency?

McKeel Hagerty (CEO)

Frank Hagerty (Founders)

Louise Hagerty (Founders)

Are You An Executive, HR Leader, Or Brand Manager At Hagerty Insurance Agency?

Claiming and updating your company profile on Zippia is free and easy.

Zippia gives an in-depth look into the details of Hagerty Insurance Agency, including salaries, political affiliations, employee data, and more, in order to inform job seekers about Hagerty Insurance Agency. The employee data is based on information from people who have self-reported their past or current employments at Hagerty Insurance Agency. While we have made attempts to ensure that the information displayed are correct, Zippia is not responsible for any errors or omissions, or for the results obtained from the use of this information. The data presented on this page does not represent the view of Hagerty Insurance Agency and its employees or that of Zippia.

Hagerty Insurance Agency may also be known as or be related to Hagerty, Hagerty (U.S.), Hagerty (u.s.), Hagerty Insurance Agency, Hagerty Insurance Agency Inc, Hagerty Insurance Agency LLC and Hagerty Insurance Agency, LLC.