New York Central Mutual salaries

Q: Is the pay good at New York Central Mutual?

Yes, the pay is good at New York Central Mutual. Compared to the industry average of $55,370 per year, the average annual salary at New York Central Mutual is $54,890, which is 0.87% lower.

Q: What is the starting pay at New York Central Mutual?

The starting pay at New York Central Mutual is $32,000 per year, or $15.38 per hour.

Q: How much does New York Central Mutual pay an hour?

New York Central Mutual pays $26.39 an hour, on average.

Zippia score 4.1

New York Central Mutual salary estimate

$54,890yearly

$26.39 hourly rate

Entry-level salary

$32,000 yearly salary

Updated December 15, 2025

New York Central Mutual Salary Insights

At New York Central Mutual, salaries reflect a wide range of positions, showcasing the company’s commitment to offering competitive compensation. The average salary for employees is $54,890, but this figure varies dramatically depending on the role. For instance, Senior Java Developers lead the pack, earning an impressive $114,252 annually, while risk managers follow closely at $112,027. In contrast, lower-paying roles such as cashiers and HVAC helpers see average earnings of $30,126.

Departmental Salary Breakdown

Salary averages also differ by department. The engineering department enjoys the highest average salary of $85,450, while customer service roles tend to be lower, averaging around $35,751. This disparity underscores the importance of departmental context when evaluating salary expectations.

Comparative Salaries

When compared to competitors like Tower Hill Insurance and GEHA Health, New York Central Mutual’s salaries are competitive. Tower Hill Insurance employees earn an average of $66,045, while GEHA Health averages $58,801. This comparative analysis assists prospective employees in gauging their potential earnings.

Highest paying jobs at New York Central Mutual

The highest paying jobs at New York Central Mutual are senior java developer, risk manager, aix administrator, and software engineer. Senior java developer jobs at New York Central Mutual earn an average yearly salary of $114,252, New York Central Mutual risk manager jobs average $112,027, and New York Central Mutual aix administrator jobs average $100,469.

The lowest paying New York Central Mutual roles include cashier and hvac helper. New York Central Mutual cashier average salary is $30,126 per year. So while the average New York Central Mutual salary is $54,890 there is a big variation in pay depending on the role.

Highest paying jobs at New York Central Mutual

Rank	Job title	Average New York Central Mutual salary	Hourly rate
1	Senior Java Developer	$114,252	$54.93
2	Risk Manager	$112,027	$53.86
3	AIX Administrator	$100,469	$48.30
4	Software Engineer	$99,601	$47.89
5	Purchasing Manager	$97,409	$46.83
6	Application Tester	$95,271	$45.80
7	Consultant	$93,314	$44.86
8	Product Designer	$90,145	$43.34
9	Software Developer	$89,044	$42.81
10	Public Relations	$81,849	$39.35
11	Programmer	$79,771	$38.35
12	Network Administrator	$74,962	$36.04
13	Medical Examiner	$74,377	$35.76
14	Liability Claims Examiner	$70,242	$33.77
15	Utilization Review Nurse	$67,170	$32.29
16	Underwriter	$67,037	$32.23
17	Finance Specialist	$66,862	$32.15
18	Marketing/Business Analyst	$62,112	$29.86
19	Market Research Analyst	$61,805	$29.71
20	Special Investigation Unit Investigator	$59,417	$28.57

Rate the fairness of New York Central Mutual's compensation policies.

How much does New York Central Mutual pay by location?

The average New York Central Mutual salary varies by location. New York Central Mutual salaries are the highest in Moonachie, NJ, at $62,614 per year. New York Central Mutual pays the second highest average salary in Washington, DC, at $62,242 per year. It's important to factor in the cost of living when negotiating a salary or choosing a place to work.

Highest paying New York Central Mutual locations

Rank	Location	Average New York Central Mutual salary	Hourly rate
1	Moonachie, NJ	$62,614	$30.10
2	Washington, DC	$62,242	$29.92
3	Hyattsville, MD	$56,427	$27.13
4	McLean, VA	$55,737	$26.80

Do you work at New York Central Mutual?

Did New York Central Mutual's compensation package meet your expectations?

New York Central Mutual salaries by department

Salaries at New York Central Mutual vary depending on the department you work in. New York Central Mutual salaries in the engineering department are the highest with an average salary of $85,450. Employees in the art/design department at New York Central Mutual receive relatively high salaries as well, with an average salary of $77,922 per year. Departments that don't pay as well at New York Central Mutual include the customer service and the administrative organizational functions, with employees earning average salaries of $35,751 and $38,753, respectively.

Average New York Central Mutual salary by department

Rank	Department	Average New York Central Mutual salary	Hourly rate
1	Engineering	$85,450	$41.08
2	Art/Design	$77,922	$37.46
3	IT	$73,846	$35.50
4	Finance	$60,968	$29.31
5	Healthcare	$60,339	$29.01
6	Plant/Manufacturing	$58,780	$28.26
7	Marketing	$58,027	$27.90
8	Research & Development	$56,038	$26.94
9	Business Development	$52,674	$25.32
10	Accounting	$48,671	$23.40
11	Warehouse	$43,657	$20.99
12	Sales	$41,512	$19.96
13	Administrative	$38,753	$18.63
14	Customer Service	$35,752	$17.19

How much does New York Central Mutual pay by department?

Best paying New York Central Mutual marketing salaries

Rank	Position	Average New York Central Mutual salary	Hourly rate
1	Pricing Analyst	$62,589	$30.09
2	Marketing/Business Analyst	$62,112	$29.86
3	Public Relations Specialist	$61,927	$29.77
4	Event Planner	$57,774	$27.78
5	Convention Planner	$49,567	$23.83
6	Marketing Internship	$33,788	$16.24

Best paying New York Central Mutual finance salaries

Rank	Position	Average New York Central Mutual salary	Hourly rate
1	Risk Manager	$112,027	$53.86
2	Consultant	$93,314	$44.86
3	Project Analyst	$78,628	$37.80
4	Liability Claims Examiner	$70,242	$33.77
5	Underwriter	$67,037	$32.23
6	Finance Specialist	$66,862	$32.15
7	Budget Analyst	$63,140	$30.36
8	Claim Processor	$54,225	$26.07
9	Claims Adjuster	$51,065	$24.55
10	Finance Internship	$40,671	$19.55
11	Insurance Clerk	$34,638	$16.65

Best paying New York Central Mutual customer service salaries

Rank	Position	Average New York Central Mutual salary	Hourly rate
1	Desktop Support Technician	$46,641	$22.42
2	Customer Relations Specialist	$42,183	$20.28
3	Customer Service Representative	$34,973	$16.81
4	Claims Clerk	$31,596	$15.19

New York Central Mutual competitors’ average salaries

Average salaries at New York Central Mutual competitors, like Tower Hill Insurance, EMC Insurance, and GEHA Health, vary. Tower Hill Insurance employees earn the highest salaries, with an average yearly salary of $66,045. The average salary at EMC Insurance is $64,189 per year, and the average salary at GEHA Health is $58,801 per year.

Highest paying New York Central Mutual competitors

Rank	Company name	Zippia score	Average salary
1	Tower Hill Insurance	4.7	$66,045
2	EMC Insurance	4.6	$64,189
3	GEHA Health	4.8	$58,801
4	American Farmers & Ranchers Mutual Insurance Company	4.0	$56,513
5	Allied Insurance Brokers	4.3	$56,479
6	Associated Third Party Administrators	4.2	$56,349
7	The Manhattan Life Insurance	3.9	$56,267
8	Penn Treaty Network America	4.1	$56,017
9	Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Louisiana	4.1	$55,231
10	Citizens Insurance Group	3.7	$55,157
11	BAShealth	3.8	$55,106
12	Stillwater Insurance	4.2	$55,001
13	Anchor General Insurance Agency	4.1	$54,824
14	Farm Bureau Mutual Insurance Company of Idaho	4.2	$53,618
15	Palisades Safety Insurance Agency, Inc.	4.1	$53,409
16	Badger Mutual	3.8	$52,548
17	Heritage Insurance Holdings	4.2	$51,812
18	Brokerage Concepts, Inc.	4.3	$50,983
19	Wellpoint Insurance Services, Inc.	4.6	$50,759
20	Mercer Insurance Group	3.7	$48,296

Recently added New York Central Mutual salaries

Job	Location	Date added	Salary
CSR (Underwriting) (Hybrid)	Edmeston, NY	06/27/2025	$31,594
Quality Assurance Specialist (Casualty Claims)	Edmeston, NY	06/14/2025	$41,156
Appraiser (Auto Claims)	Buffalo, NY	06/11/2025	$60,500
Auto Physical Damage Examiner (Hybrid)	Edmeston, NY	05/24/2025	$43,000
Underwriter (Hybrid)	Edmeston, NY	05/24/2025	$45,500

Frequently asked questions about New York Central Mutual salaries

Is the pay good at New York Central Mutual?

What is the starting pay at New York Central Mutual?

How much does New York Central Mutual pay an hour?

Have more questions? See all answers to common company questions.

Search for jobs

Companies
New York
Edmeston, NY
New York Central Mutual
New York Central Mutual Salaries

Updated December 15, 2025

Zippia gives an in-depth look into the details of New York Central Mutual, including salaries, political affiliations, employee data, and more, in order to inform job seekers about New York Central Mutual. The employee data is based on information from people who have self-reported their past or current employments at New York Central Mutual. The data on this page is also based on data sources collected from public and open data sources on the Internet and other locations, as well as proprietary data we licensed from other companies. Sources of data may include, but are not limited to, the BLS, company filings, estimates based on those filings, H1B filings, and other public and private datasets. While we have made attempts to ensure that the information displayed are correct, Zippia is not responsible for any errors or omissions or for the results obtained from the use of this information. None of the information on this page has been provided or approved by New York Central Mutual. The data presented on this page does not represent the view of New York Central Mutual and its employees or that of Zippia.

New York Central Mutual may also be known as or be related to NYCM Insurance and New York Central Mutual.