Explore jobs
Find specific jobs
Explore careers
Explore professions
Best companies
Explore companies
The job market today is tough. It doesn’t matter how much experience or training you have you might find yourself competing with many people for just one position. Especially, if you’re looking to get a job as a payroll specialist.
At Zippia, we’re experts in everything related to employment. That means we have access to some of the most common interview questions and specifically, interview questions for payroll specialists. We’ve compiled some of these questions and answers so you can prepare for your job interview and land your dream job.
Key Takeaways:
Payroll specialist candidates should research the company and review the application materials before the start of the interview.
Interviewers should review the job description and review the candidates resume before the start of the interview.
Looking for a job? These position are hiring now near you:
The payroll specialist profession very heavily relies on math skills, knowledge of the law, and the ability to stay abreast of industry changes. That means that there will be questions in your interview that probably won’t crop up in other job interviews.
The questions below might be ones you encounter. We’re providing you with some possible answers, but you will, of course, provide your answers.
Tell me about yourself. This is a common interview question often asked at the start of the interview. Your answer should highlight your relevant skills and qualifications.
Example Answer:
I have been working as a payroll specialist for the past five years with experiences in both corporate and third-party payroll service provider environments. I have a solid understanding of payroll processes, including calculating wages, deductions, and benefits.
Throughout my career, I have developed and honed my skills with attention to detail and accuracy and ensuring timely and error-free payroll processing. I am highly committed to maintaining confidentiality and data security when handling sensitive employee information. I am excited about the opportunity to contribute my skills and knowledge to your organization.
Where do you see yourself in five years? This question is asked to get an understanding of your long-term goals and how their company fits into those goals. Be sure your response shows your ambition, growth, and alignment with the company's goals.
Example Answer:
In five years, I hope to make a meaningful impact on the company's payroll operations and contribute to its overall growth and success. To do this I hope to progress into a leadership position within the payroll department such as payroll supervisor or manager.
I see myself playing an active role in process improvement initiatives related to payroll operations. I am passionate about this profession and committed to continuously expanding my knowledge and skills to help me be a valuable member of this team and lead this company to success.
What are your major professional accomplishments? The interviewer is looking to see if you back back up what your resume says. Your answer should showcase a time when you used your skills and experiences to make an impact to the field.
Example Answer:
My top achievement so far is when I successfully led a payroll system implementation project for my previous company. The process involved transitioning from a manual payroll process to an automated system.
To be able to do this project, I collaborated with cross-functional teams, which included FR, IT, and finance, to gather requirements, design work flows, and customize the payroll software to meet our specific needs. One the system was put into place, we saw a reduction in payroll processing time, it eliminated manual errors, and it enhanced data security.
Why do you want to work here? Your answer should show your genuine interest in the position and the company. It should also include information that you found during your research of the company. Your personal values should also align with the company values. You want to sell yourself to the interviewer so they want to hire you
Example Answer:
I want to work here because I am drawn to your company's dedication to employee development and fostering a positive work culture. I believe that a supportive and collaborative work environment is crucial for professional growth and job satisfaction.
What are your strengths and weaknesses? When discussing your weaknesses, be sure that you do it in a constructive manner. You should showcase your self-awareness and what steps you are taking to improve your weaknesses to turn them into something positive.
Example Answer:
My attention to detail is probably my greatest strength. I have a meticulous approach to my work which helps me have accurate and an error-free payroll process. I am always sure I am thorough in reviewing my data, calculations, and documents to maintain the highest level of accuracy.
While my attention to detail is my greatest strength, it can sometimes hinder my ability to delegate my work. However, I am aware that delegation is essential for fostering teamwork and helping others develop their skills, I am seeking opportunity to delegate and empower colleagues to contribute their expertise.
What payroll systems do you have experience with and how would you classify your experience. There’s a chance that you have experience in the system that they use, but there are so many different systems out there that it’s probably more than likely that you won’t have had this experience.
The most important thing is to stress that you have experience using this type of software and that you are confident that you can learn a different system.
Example Answer:
I have extensive experience with QuickBooks Payroll as that is what I used at my last job. I’ve also used Paycor in the past but would need a bit of a refresher to get back up to speed on that. I do have Gusto experience but that has changed a bit so I might need to relearn it. I am quite confident in my abilities to use any payroll system after proper training.
Have you ever had to implement or switch payroll systems? If you have experience in this, detail what you’ve done. You can even ask if they’re considering this and what systems they use and are thinking about switching to.
If you can answer this directly, then your experience can be directly useful. This can be an involved answer and include a lot of back and forth.
Example Answer:
I was involved in a switch from Paycor to QuickBooks, but this happened just as I entered the company, so my role was minimal and mainly involved transferring files. From what I heard from my supervisor, the switch was relatively easy but time-consuming.
How familiar are you with FLSA? The recruiter or hiring professional just wants to know that you know what FLSA is and how to use it. To be fair, any payroll specialist who doesn’t know what this is probably isn’t very good at their job.
You don’t need to spell out what FLSA is or what its purpose is, just knowing what it is and being able to explain how it is used can be all they need.
Example Answer:
I am very familiar with the Fair Labor Standards Act as it dictates just about everything in my profession. I use it regularly, not just for information regarding legal payment procedures in this country, but I often also refer employees to certain sections of it when they have questions about their pay.
What is a W2, a W4, and a 941? The interviewer might know the difference, but they certainly don’t need a long, drawn-out explanation. They’re checking to see what you know, much like the question above.
Example Answer:
A W2 is a standard tax form that reports to the government the amount of taxes and withholdings for each employee. A W4 is a form an employee fills out to let the employer know how much to withhold for taxes. And a 941 is what employers complete and send to the government quarterly to update them on withholdings for employees.
What forms does an employee complete to get paid? It might vary if your company does direct deposit but there are just a few basic pieces of information you need from the employee.
Example Answer:
From the employee I might need eligibility to work in the United States paperwork, I’ll need their social security number, and I’ll need them to complete a W4 for withholdings. Of course, I’ll then need information on how to pay them, like what their address is or if they’d like direct deposit.
How do you handle an employee having their wages garnished? This is a frequent occurrence, and it can be very complicated. You don’t need to go into great detail in answering the question, but the employer wants to know that you understand this complicated procedure.
Example Answer:
First of all, we keep garnishments secret. The human resources and payroll staff is not allowed to discuss this at all unless it’s with qualified people who are working on the garnishment. My employer does not charge an administrative fee, so our steps are pretty straightforward but lengthy.
We comply with the order as received, we have had to check with the courts and attorneys at times to get clarification on certain items. Copies of all paperwork are put in a file and in the computer system to prevent confusion. We also communicate with the employee regarding the garnishment. Usually, we do this in our office and have them sign a document stating that they understand we’ll be docking their wages.
We also send a follow-up email and ask them to digitally acknowledge it and respond to us. After that, we take the steps necessary to ensure that the garnished amounts go where they’re supposed to, including a paper trail of this information and payments paid.
Tell us about a time when you’ve made a mistake at work and how you fixed it? This question has a double role. It shows how you handle making an error and your skill level in rectifying the situation. Now you probably won’t have the same answer as our imaginary interviewee, but you get the idea.
You should deal with both aspects of this question in your answer. Your prospective boss doesn’t expect you to be perfect, but they do expect an appropriate response when an error is made.
Example Answer:
I recently miskeyed an employee’s deductions. The employee brought this to my attention, and it turns out that we had been taking too much money from their tax withholdings for a month. I apologized to the employee, who was very kind about the situation. Then I reported the issue to my boss so a record could be made for our files.
At that point, I needed to fix the problem. I amended their deductions and filed a Form 941-X. This reported the error to the government and gave us a paper trail. Then I was able to withhold less from the employee’s next check, so they recovered the lost money. The following paycheck was then corrected, and the appropriate amount was deducted.
What are the differences between regular and contract employees? Whether you deal with contract employees or not at your job, you should be able to list some of the differences.
Example Answer:
We don’t have many contractors and none regularly. But our contractors provide us with a W4 although we do not take any deductions, nor do we pay them any benefits. Then, instead of a W2 at the end of the year, they receive a 1099 form. We also provide all of the paperwork necessary for sending them the 1099 form, just as we do with W2s and our regular employees.
What are non-taxable wages? You should know the answer to this, at least how it relates to your current business.
Example Answer:
Publication 525 by the IRS is the best reference for this. In my current business, all the earnings our employees make are taxable. This includes their bonuses. We do have situations where some of the employee’s income goes into things like health savings accounts where they are not taxed. Likewise, matching contributions from an employer aren’t taxed.
Speaking of HSAs, what are some voluntary deductions? This should be an easy question for you to answer. It’s one that many employees might even be able to answer without all of your years of work experience.
Example Answer:
Voluntary deductions from payroll are amounts that employees want to have taken out for things like an HSA or life insurance or healthcare. Some deductions are taxable, some aren’t. The ones above aren’t. If They aren’t taxes, they’re taken from the gross pay immediately. If they are taxable, then they’re taken from the gross pay after the taxes have been figured on that amount.
How do you follow changes in tax laws? This question will have to be answered honestly and based upon your experience. Knowing about multiple resources for information will put you in a good light.
Example Answer:
Well, IRS.gov is a good place to visit for tax laws and changes, especially for those that deal with employees. But I also subscribe to a newsletter for other payroll specialists working in healthcare.
This newsletter does a great job of breaking down the government’s changes into categories that are applicable and then explaining the changes. Sometimes the IRS website is difficult to navigate as they give all changes equal weight. I’m only interested in the changes that affect my industry, so the newsletter is the best place to go.
What do you think is the most important skill for a payroll clerk to have? Be truthful and answer with your honest opinion. There is validity to just about any answer here, as long as you can explain yourself well.
Example Answer:
I feel that being good with numbers is an asset in this job. Having that analytical mind helps with calculations and even working with excel spreadsheets. But I think being a people person is equally important in this job. Most of your day you won’t be working with others, but when you do it’s often a tense situation, and being someone they’re comfortable with and they trust and respect can go a long way to diffuse difficult situations.
How do you maintain employee confidentiality? Discretion is a huge part of your job because you’re dealing with very sensitive data. Share, if you can, the steps are in place at your company to protect confidentiality. Make sure to stress that you can be trusted.
Example Answer:
Our company system has very secure firewalls so no one can hack into the system. There is no paper trail related to sensitive information, like social security numbers. It’s about as safe as you can get because our company is very diligent. Likewise, I never share private information with our employees. Quite frankly, we have such a large group of employees that I couldn’t even recall specifics from someone’s bank, personal, or payroll information without looking it up.
Tell me about the responsibilities you had in your last job as a payroll specialist. This question is specific to you and your situation. We can’t answer it for you, but we can tell you that the more detail you can provide, the better.
This is where practicing can come in handy. It will help you remember some tasks you do infrequently that are important but might slip your mind when you’re on the spot and nervous.
Example Answer:
I currently work as a payroll specialist at XYC Corporation and my job is to collect employee hours and implement that data into our payroll software. I’m also responsible for updating all information as there are changes in individual situations or as we add and subtract employees from the company.
I am also responsible for staying on top of all payroll and tax law changes and relating that information to management. If an employee has specific questions, sometimes I’m asked to help HR provide them with an answer.
Why do you want to continue working in this business? Let them know how passionate you are about the industry.
Example Answer:
I spent years training to become a junior payroll specialist and then I spent five years in that role. At this point in my career, I certainly don’t want out, I want to dive in deeper. That’s why I’m excited about this senior role with your company.
I know I’m ready for more responsibility and I like the fact that it’s a smaller company. This means I can get to know more about this profession rather than simply entering numbers. I love what I do and I’m ready to learn more.
Can you explain the difference between gross pay and net pay, and how they are calculated?
How familiar are you with payroll software systems, and can you provide an example of one you have used in the past?
Can you describe the process you would follow to ensure accurate and timely processing of employee payroll?
How do you handle deductions such as taxes, benefits, and retirement contributions in payroll calculations?
Have you ever encountered a situation where an employee's pay was incorrect due to an error in data entry? How did you identify and rectify the error?
What steps do you take to stay updated with changes in payroll laws, regulations, and tax rates?
Can you outline the process you follow to reconcile payroll reports and resolve any discrepancies?
Describe a situation where you had to handle a payroll-related inquiry or complaint from an employee. How did you handle it, and what was the outcome?
How do you maintain confidentiality and data security when handling sensitive employee payroll information?
Are you familiar with any payroll audits or compliance requirements, and how do you ensure adherence to these regulations?
Looking for a job? These position are hiring now near you:
Here are some tips to help you prepare for you next payroll specialist interview.
As a Candidate:
Review application materials. If you’re in the middle of an active job search, you’ve applied to a lot of jobs and the descriptions may have blurred a bit in your mind.
That’s okay as long as you have your application materials available. Reread the job posting, look at your cover letter, and your resume. This will make you better prepared for the interview.
Research the company. Make sure you dive deep into information on the company. Start with their website, then look at their reviews on sites like Glassdoor, and finally, simply google the company to see what news there is.
Compile questions. As you’re researching the company, start preparing a list of questions that you want to ask. It makes a good impression on the company if you show your interest level by asking questions. On top of that, you probably have some things you will need to know before you decide to take a job.
Professionalism. Present yourself in your most professional way. This includes bringing any information you may need to the interview, dressing to impress, speaking professionally, and carrying yourself with authority.
Practice. This is where the questions below will come in handy. It’s not just about knowing what questions will be asked and knowing how you’ll answer. To fully prepare and present yourself with confidence, you should practice. This can mean looking in a mirror and answering the questions. Or it can be recruiting a friend to role-play with you.
As an Interviewer:
Review the job description. Reviewing the job description can help you get an understanding of what the job requirements are and what your ideal candidate is. It will also help you tailor your questions to the job and what is needed to fill the position.
Create interview questions. The questions you create should be a mixture of common interview questions along with payroll specialist behavioral interview questions. Asking behavioral questions to candidates will help you evaluate their skills and determine how they would handle specific situations.
Review the candidates resume. Before the start of the interview, review the candidates resume to get familiar with their skills, qualifications, and experiences. This will also help you create candidate specific questions to help you get to know them better.
Take notes. During the interview, take notes on what the candidate says and how they answer the questions. You should also make notes on the skills they highlight. Your notes will also help a helpful resource when it comes time to evaluate the candidates later on.
If you’re not familiar with the position, a payroll specialist is tasked with preparing the payroll for a company. They are also often responsible for gathering other information from the employees, managing that data, using financial software, and handling payroll taxes.
Usually, a payroll specialist works within the human resources department and may have to know quite a bit about HR matters, too. This is an important position that requires extensive knowledge and constantly staying abreast of changes in tax and employment laws.
If you’re serious about getting a new job, then you need to put in the work and prepare for your interview. You’ve already done so much work getting your cover letter and resume together, it’d be a shame to waste that because you’re unprepared.
Of course, an interview to be a payroll specialist is not a test. So you don’t have to worry about right and wrong answers or memorizing. Your preparation is really to help build your confidence and refresh your memory. Once you feel that’s done, then you’re ready.