Pilgrim Insurance competitors

Zippia score 3.8

Pilgrim Insurance main competitors are The Hanover Insurance Group, First Mercury Financial, and Arbella Insurance.

Competitor Summary. See how Pilgrim Insurance compares to its main competitors:

St. Paul Fire & Marine Insurance Co has the most employees (10,000).
Employees at The Hanover Insurance Group earn more than most of the competitors, with an average yearly salary of $71,343.

Work at Pilgrim Insurance?

Share your experience

Pilgrim Insurance vs competitors

Company	Founding date	Zippia score	Headquarters	# of Locations	Revenue	Employees
Pilgrim Insurance	1987	3.8	Boston, MA	1	$8.5M	75
Arbella Insurance	1997	4.6	Quincy, MA	3	$660.0M	1,000
The Hanover Insurance Group	1852	4.9	Worcester, MA	38	$5.2B	4,600
Massachusetts Property Insurance Underwriting Association	-	3.6	Boston, MA	1	$1.9M	50
The Ohio Casualty Insurance Company	1919	4.4	Fairfield, OH	1	$1.5B	2,114
Indiana Insurance Company	1851	4.0	Loveland, OH	1	$560.0M	750
St. Paul Fire & Marine Insurance Co	1853	4.3	Saint Paul, MN	1	$6.5B	10,000
Quincy Mutual Group	1851	3.9	Quincy, MA	2	$6.3M	20
Continental Western Group (a W. R. Berkley Company)	-	2.6	Luverne, MN	5	$160,000	350
Anchor General Insurance Agency	1995	4.1	San Diego, CA	1	$56.1M	350
Rockingham Insurance	1869	3.2	Harrisonburg, VA	1	$690,000	4
Northland Insurance	-	4.0	Saint Paul, MN	1	$31.3M	35
Service Lloyds	1982	3.5	Austin, TX	1	$15.0M	100
Rain and Hail Insurance	1919	4.3	Johnston, IA	10	$49.9M	600
The Frank Gates Service Company	1946	4.0	Dublin, OH	1	$170.0M	300
First Mercury Financial	1993	4.0	Southfield, MI	1	$197.6M	350
Atlantic Mutual Insurance Company	1838	3.5	New York, NY	1	$3.6M	5
National States Insurance	-	3.7	Saint Louis, MO	1	$2.1M	100
Wawanesa Mutual Insurance Co	1974	4.1	San Diego, CA	1	$296.8M	5,900
The Underwriters Group	1941	4.3	Louisville, KY	1	$73.0M	50
Western General Insurance	1971	4.4	Calabasas, CA	1	$88.0M	150

Rate Pilgrim Insurance's competitiveness in the market.

Pilgrim Insurance salaries vs competitors

Among Pilgrim Insurance competitors, employees at The Hanover Insurance Group earn the most with an average yearly salary of $71,343.

Compare Pilgrim Insurance salaries vs competitors

Company	Average salary	Hourly salary	Salary score
Pilgrim Insurance	$54,291	$26.10	-
Arbella Insurance	$60,273	$28.98	-
The Hanover Insurance Group	$71,343	$34.30	-
Massachusetts Property Insurance Underwriting Association	$54,411	$26.16	-
The Ohio Casualty Insurance Company	$57,046	$27.43	-
Indiana Insurance Company	$54,742	$26.32	-

Compare Pilgrim Insurance job title salaries vs competitors

Company	Highest salary	Hourly salary
Pilgrim Insurance	$80,155	$38.54
Quincy Mutual Group	$91,241	$43.87
The Hanover Insurance Group	$90,826	$43.67
The Ohio Casualty Insurance Company	$87,241	$41.94
Indiana Insurance Company	$86,980	$41.82
Rockingham Insurance	$86,210	$41.45
Massachusetts Property Insurance Underwriting Association	$85,872	$41.28
St. Paul Fire & Marine Insurance Co	$84,932	$40.83
Atlantic Mutual Insurance Company	$83,866	$40.32
Continental Western Group (a W. R. Berkley Company)	$83,633	$40.21
Northland Insurance	$83,470	$40.13
Rain and Hail Insurance	$82,894	$39.85
Anchor General Insurance Agency	$82,310	$39.57
Service Lloyds	$81,655	$39.26
Wawanesa Mutual Insurance Co	$77,912	$37.46
Western General Insurance	$77,501	$37.26
The Underwriters Group	$76,635	$36.84
The Frank Gates Service Company	$76,054	$36.56
First Mercury Financial	$74,593	$35.86
National States Insurance	$73,471	$35.32

Do you work at Pilgrim Insurance?

Is Pilgrim Insurance able to compete effectively with similar companies?

Pilgrim Insurance jobs

Pilgrim Insurance demographics vs competitors

Compare gender at Pilgrim Insurance vs competitors

Job title	Male	Female
Wawanesa Mutual Insurance Co	42%	58%
The Hanover Insurance Group	48%	52%
Pilgrim Insurance	-	-

Male

Female

100%

75%

50%

25%

Pilgrim Insurance

The Hanover Insurance Group

Wawanesa Mutual Insurance Co

25%

50%

75%

100%

Compare race at Pilgrim Insurance vs competitors

Company	White	Hispanic or Latino	Black or African American	Asian	Unknown	Diversity score
The Hanover Insurance Group	64%	11%	10%	11%	4%	9.8
Wawanesa Mutual Insurance Co	48%	27%	7%	14%	4%	8.3

Pilgrim Insurance and similar companies CEOs

CEOBio

John Conner Roche

The Hanover Insurance Group

John C. Roche became President and Chief Executive Officer in November 2017. Prior to that, he served as Executive Vice President and President, Hanover Agency Markets since February 2017. Until February 2017, Mr. Roche was Executive Vice President, President Business Insurance since 2013 and head of Field Operations since November 2014. Prior to that he served as Senior Vice President, President Business Insurance from 2009 to 2013 and has held the following other positions since joining the Company in 2006: Vice President, Field Operations and Vice President, Underwriting and Product Management, Commercial Lines. From 1994 to 2006, Mr. Roche served in a variety of leadership positions at St. Paul Travelers Companies, Inc., last serving as Vice President, Commercial Accounts. Previously, Mr. Roche served in a variety of underwriting and management positions at Fireman’s Fund Insurance Company and Atlantic Mutual Insurance Company.

Mr. Kenneth E. McCrea

Wawanesa Mutual Insurance Co

Mr. Kenneth E. McCrea is a President and Chief Executive Officer at Wawanesa Insurance and is based in United States.

Ademayowa Adeduro

Anchor General Insurance Agency

Ademayowa Adedurowork atAnchor General Insurance Agency and a Chief Executive at Anchor General Insurance Agency and are based in Nigeria.