Utica Mutual Insurance Company Overview

Utica National Insurance group provides first-class insurance for home, auto, and businesses via local, trusted, independent agents.
The staff at Utica Mutual Insurance Company come from unusually diverse demographic backgrounds. The company is 50.1% female and 38.1% ethnic minorities. Utica Mutual Insurance Company employees are slightly more likely to be members of the Republican Party than the Democratic Party, with 52.0% of employees identifying as members of the Republican Party. Despite their political differences, employees at Utica Mutual Insurance Company seem to be happy. The company has great employee retention with staff members usually staying for 5.5 years. The average employee at Utica Mutual Insurance Company makes $49,992 per year. Pay at Utica Mutual Insurance Company is significantly lower than some of its highest paying competitors, like Penn National Insurance, The Hanover Insurance Group, and QBE Insurance, which pay $75,022, $68,031, and $66,969, respectively.
A large insurance company with 1,071 employees and an annual revenue of $732.6M, Utica Mutual Insurance Company is headquartered in New York.

The Organization’s Mission

To continually meet the needs of our policyholders, agent/customers and employees resulting in sustainable profitable growth in an increasingly competitive marketplace. We are proud to sell our products through more than 2,200 independent insurance agents around the country as we have been since 1928.

Industry

Insurance

Revenue

$732.6M

Employees

1,071

Founded in

1914

Headquarters

New Hartford, NY

Website

www.uticanational.com

Organization Type

Private

Is This Your Company?

Utica Mutual Insurance Company Employee Reviews

Zippia Official Logo

1.0

Zippia UserMay 2019

1.0

Zippia Official LogoZippia UserMay 2019

What Do You Like About Working There?

Nothing really. However, some of the people are very nice.

What DON'T You Like About Working There?

They pay really poorly. They try to keep people at the bottom of the pay scale.

What Are Your Favorite Benefits/Perks?

Free drink Mondays
Anonymous review of Utica Mutual Insurance Company

Do you work at Utica Mutual Insurance Company? Rate Utica Mutual Insurance Company as an Employer.

How would you rate working at Utica Mutual Insurance Company?

Work at Utica Mutual Insurance Company? Share your experience anonymously.

What do you like about working for Utica Mutual Insurance Company?

The Team At Utica Mutual Insurance Company

Key People
  • Richard Creedon (CEO)

Utica Mutual Insurance Company Company Rankings

Utica Mutual Insurance Company is ranked #11 on the Best Insurance Companies to Work For in America list. Zippia's Best Places to Work lists provide unbiased, data-based evaluations of companies. Rankings are based on government and proprietary data on salaries, company financial health, and employee diversity.

Read more about how we rank companies.

Utica Mutual Insurance Company Salaries

How much does Utica Mutual Insurance Company pay?
The national average salary for a Utica Mutual Insurance Company employee in the United States is $49,992 per year. Employees in the top 10 percent can make over $88,000 per year, while employees at the bottom 10 percent earn less than $28,000 per year.
9.7
Salary Score
Average Employee Earnings

Utica Mutual Insurance Company Salaries By Job Title

While Utica Mutual Insurance Company employees earn an average yearly salary of $49,992, different roles can command different wages. Some of the positions that earn high wages at Utica Mutual Insurance Company include project manager, design checker, oracle database administrator, and net developer. A typical project manager salary at Utica Mutual Insurance Company is $100,317 per year. Some of the other roles at Utica Mutual Insurance Company are home health aid and housekeeper. A worker with the title home health aid at Utica Mutual Insurance Company earns an average salary of $27,100 per year.
Job Title
Title
ascdesc
Average Salarydesc
Project Manager
Salary Range87k - 114k$100k$100,317
Design Checker
Salary Range91k - 107k$99k$99,092
Oracle Database Administrator
Salary Range92k - 102k$98k$97,569
NET Developer
Salary Range89k - 101k$95k$95,322
Java Developer
Salary Range87k - 102k$95k$94,836
Lead Technician
Salary Range87k - 100k$94k$93,811
Business Consultant
Salary Range79k - 91k$85k$85,315
Senior Auditor
Salary Range79k - 86k$83k$82,557
Sales Associate
Salary Range75k - 88k$82k$81,664
Staff Attorney
Salary Range76k - 86k$81k$81,423
$60k
$114k

Jobs from similar companies

Utica Mutual Insurance Company Careers

On average, employees at Utica Mutual Insurance Company stay with the company for 5.5 years. Employees most commonly join Utica Mutual Insurance Company after leaving The Hartford. When they leave Utica Mutual Insurance Company, they most frequently get their next job at MetLife.

Average Length of Employment

6.2 years

Top Employers Before Utica Mutual Insurance Company

8.2 %

Top Employers After Utica Mutual Insurance Company

13.4 %
9.6 %

Jobs from similar companies

Utica Mutual Insurance Company Employee Demographics

9.8
Diversity Score
We calculated the diversity score of companies by measuring multiple factors, including the ethnic background, gender identity, and language skills of their workforce.

Jobs from companies you might like

Utica Mutual Insurance Company Employees Education

Of the 1,071 employees at Utica Mutual Insurance Company, 25.6% attended Utica College. Employees at Utica Mutual Insurance Company most frequently majored in Business, and most employees’ highest level of education is a Bachelors.

Do you Work At Utica Mutual Insurance Company?

Help us make this company more transparent.

Utica Mutual Insurance Company Employee Political Affiliation

Utica Mutual Insurance Company employees are most likely to be members of the Republican Party. The largest donation made to a political party by a Utica Mutual Insurance Company employee was by James Robinson. James Robinson donated $8,500 to the Republican Party.

Employee Political Donations

NameascdescJob TitleascdescPartyascdescDonationascdesc
James RobinsonChairperson, Board Of Directors
Chairperson, Board Of Directors
Republican Party
$8,500Republican Party
Kristen MartinAdministration
Administration
Republican Party
$4,800Republican Party
Justin LatusInformation Engineer
Information Engineer
Democratic Party
$1,000Democratic Party
William HarrisPhysician
Physician
Republican Party
$850Republican Party
Douglas RobinsonChief Executive Officer
Chief Executive Officer
Republican Party
$500Republican Party
Bernard TuriAttorney
Attorney
Democratic Party
$400Democratic Party
Pamela PaineClaims Manager
Claims Manager
Democratic Party
$300Democratic Party
Denise SOGUnderwriter
Underwriter
Democratic Party
$270Democratic Party
Melissa MannUnderwriting Director
Underwriting Director
Democratic Party
$250Democratic Party
Rajeev PangarkarChief Executive Officer
Chief Executive Officer
Republican Party
$250Republican Party
Show More

Utica Mutual Insurance Company Financial Performance

9.6
Performance Score
We calculated the performance score of companies by measuring multiple factors, including revenue, longevity, and stock market performance.

Revenue

$100M - $1B

Founded in

1914

Organization type

Private

How Would You Rate The Company Culture Of Utica Mutual Insurance Company?

Have you worked at Utica Mutual Insurance Company? Help other job seekers by rating Utica Mutual Insurance Company.

Utica Mutual Insurance Company Competitors

Some of the competitors of Utica Mutual Insurance Company are Penn National Insurance, The Hanover Insurance Group, and QBE Insurance. The wages at Penn National Insurance average higher than the other similar companies, where the median salary is $75,022 per year. The salaries at The Hanover Insurance Group average $68,031 per year, and the salaries at QBE Insurance come in at $66,969 per year.
Companydesc
Average Salarydesc

Penn National Insurance

Salary Range55k - 101k$75k$75,022
The Hanover Insurance Group
Salary Range50k - 91k$68k$68,031
QBE Insurance
Salary Range48k - 92k$67k$66,969
Selective Insurance
Salary Range49k - 89k$67k$66,691

Highlands Insurance Group

Salary Range41k - 84k$59k$59,024
Chubb
Salary Range41k - 79k$57k$57,278

Kentucky Employers' Mutual Insurance

Salary Range39k - 78k$56k$55,848
Arbella Insurance Group
Salary Range40k - 74k$55k$55,327

Wausau Insurance

Salary Range39k - 75k$54k$54,309

United Fire Group

Salary Range40k - 70k$53k$53,450
$29k
$101k

Frequently Asked Questions about Utica Mutual Insurance Company

When was Utica Mutual Insurance Company founded?

Utica Mutual Insurance Company was founded in 1914.

How many Employees does Utica Mutual Insurance Company have?

Utica Mutual Insurance Company has 1,071 employees.

How much money does Utica Mutual Insurance Company make?

Utica Mutual Insurance Company generates $732.6M in revenue.

What industry is Utica Mutual Insurance Company in?

Utica Mutual Insurance Company is in the insurance industry.

What is Utica Mutual Insurance Company's mission?

Utica Mutual Insurance Company's mission statement is "To continually meet the needs of our policyholders, agent/customers and employees resulting in sustainable profitable growth in an increasingly competitive marketplace. We are proud to sell our products through more than 2,200 independent insurance agents around the country as we have been since 1928."

What type of company is Utica Mutual Insurance Company?

Utica Mutual Insurance Company is a private company.

Who are Utica Mutual Insurance Company's competitors?

Utica Mutual Insurance Company competitors include Chubb, The Hanover Insurance Group, Foremost Insurance Group, Travelers, Progressive, Penn National Insurance, Farm Family Casualty Insurance Company, Indiana Insurance Company, EMC Insurance Group, United Fire Group, Highlands Insurance Group, QBE Holdings, QBE Insurance, The Ohio Casualty Insurance Company, Safeco, Wausau Insurance, Arbella Insurance Group, New York Central Mutual Fire Insurance Company, Selective Insurance, Kentucky Employers' Mutual Insurance.

Who works at Utica Mutual Insurance Company?

Richard Creedon (CEO)

Are You An Executive, HR Leader, Or Brand Manager At Utica Mutual Insurance Company?

Claiming and updating your company profile on Zippia is free and easy.

Updated October 27, 2021

Zippia gives an in-depth look into the details of Utica Mutual Insurance Company, including salaries, political affiliations, employee data, and more, in order to inform job seekers about Utica Mutual Insurance Company. The employee data is based on information from people who have self-reported their past or current employments at Utica Mutual Insurance Company. While we have made attempts to ensure that the information displayed are correct, Zippia is not responsible for any errors or omissions, or for the results obtained from the use of this information. The data presented on this page does not represent the view of Utica Mutual Insurance Company and its employees or that of Zippia.

Utica Mutual Insurance Company may also be known as or be related to UTICA MUTUAL INSURANCE CO INC, Utica Mutual Insurance Company, Utica Mutual Insurance Company Inc, Utica Mutual Insurance Company, Inc., Utica National Insurance and Utica National Insurance Group.