Annual performance reviews summary. Annual performance reviews are a common tool employed by companies to assess the skills and productivity of workers. While this tool is vital for some companies, not all opt to use it.
So, if you’re an employer looking to keep up with the latest performance review trends or a job seeker wanting to find or avoid companies that use annual performance reviews, you’re in luck. We’ve gathered everything you need to know about the percentage of companies that use annual performance reviews. According to our research:
-
Only 49% of companies are using annual performance reviews in 2023.
That’s down from 82% in 2016, 65% in 2017, 58% in 2018, and 54% in 2019, showing the sharp, year-over-year decline in annual performance reviews by companies in the US.
Share of companies using annual performance reviews over time
Year Share of companies 2023 49% 2019 54% 2018 58% 2017 65% 2016 82% -
The share of companies using annual performance reviews has decreased by over 40% since 2016.
In less than a decade, the share of companies using annual performance reviews has fallen by almost half. Now, less than half of all companies use them.
-
55% of workers don’t believe annual review improve their performance.
This is because performance evaluations tend to be highly formal and organized, often lacking space for open dialogue. Employees feel uneasy, and excessive formality might discourage them from being receptive to constructive feedback. Ultimately, this contributes to why fewer and fewer companies do annual performance reviews.
-
77% of HR leaders say annual reviews are not an accurate representation of employees’ work.
Believe it or not, 90% of HR believe their performance management systems (PM systems), do not yield accurate information. This can make it incredibly difficult for companies to access employees.
-
80% of workers prefer immediate feedback over annual performance reviews.
Workers actually do want feedback and constructive criticism, just not in the form of an annual performance review. The vast majority instead prefer to be given feedback in the moment, so they can improve right away.
-
Companies with continuous performance reviews outperform their competition by 24%.
24% might not seem like a lot, but it would mean the difference between 5 tasks being completed instead of 4, or a profit of $620,000 compared to $500,000.
Performance management FAQ
-
What is performance management?
Performance management is the process of enhancing and sustaining employee job performance. Doing so involves utilizing performance assessment tools, offering coaching and guidance, and consistently delivering feedback.
In the past, annual performance reviews were a common method of doing so, but in recent years, many companies and employees have started to favor immediate feedback.
This has led to discussions about how performance management should be done, and new innovations for companies. Ultimately, companies will always need to keep up with new trends and listen to employees in order to have effective performance management.
-
Why is performance management important?
Performance management is important because it enables managers to monitor employees and discover who might need further guidance or training. In more detail, here are out top 10 reasons why performance management is important:
-
Goal Achievement. PM helps align individual employees with company goals, ensuring that efforts are directed toward strategic priorities.
-
Enhanced Productivity. By identifying strengths and areas for improvement, PM enables employees to work more efficiently and effectively.
-
Employee Development. PM provides a solid framework for coaching, mentoring, and skill enhancement, contributing to professional growth and career advancement.
-
Feedback and Recognition. Regular feedback fosters a culture of communication, enabling employees to understand their contributions and receive recognition for their achievements.
-
Motivation. Clear performance expectations motivate employees to strive for goals and higher levels of performance.
-
Identification of Issues. PM helps pinpoint problems early, allowing for timely interventions and preventing potential performance-related challenges.
-
Data-Driven Decisions. By collecting and analyzing performance data, organizations can make informed decisions about resource allocation, training needs, and process improvements.
-
Employee Engagement. Involving employees in the PM process increases their sense of ownership and engagement with their work.
-
Accountability. Clearly defined performance metrics and goals create a sense of accountability among employees, fostering a culture of responsibility.
-
Continuous Improvement. PM encourages a cycle of continuous improvement by assessing outcomes, identifying gaps, and adapting strategies accordingly.
-
-
What are the elements of performance management?
There are 5 major elements of performance management, including goal setting, monitoring, feedback and coaching, performance appraisal, and rewards and recognition. To learn more about all of these important elements, here they are listed:
-
Goal Setting. This element requires clearly specific performance goals that employees should strive to achieve. These goals are aligned with the organization’s objectives and provide employees with a sense of direction.
-
Performance Monitoring. Regularly tracking and measuring employee performance against the established goals and expectations. This includes collecting data, assessing progress, and identifying any gaps.
-
Feedback and Coaching. Providing continuous feedback to employees about their performance, strengths, areas for improvement, and developmental opportunities. Then, coaching allows for guiding employees toward enhancing their skills and achieving their goals.
-
Performance Appraisal. Conducting formal performance reviews or evaluations at specific intervals to assess an employee’s overall performance and provide a comprehensive assessment of their achievements and areas for development.
-
Rewards and Recognition. Recognizing and rewarding employees for their exceptional performance, achievements, and contributions. This can include promotions, salary increases, bonuses, or other forms of recognition.
All in all, these elements work in tandem to create successful performance management, and without them, there is often a disconnect between employers and employees.
-
Conclusion
Annual performance reviews are a largely outdated method of performance management in 2023. While over 80% of companies used this method in 2016, only 49% are doing so now.
And there’s a reason why, as the majority of employees and HR professionals find annual performance reviews inaccurate and ineffective for improving performance.
Going forward, companies will likely prefer more immediate methods of providing feedback to employees, as this is what employees prefer and has proven to offer better results.
References
Author
Jack Flynn is a writer for Zippia. In his professional career he’s written over 100 research papers, articles and blog posts. Some of his most popular published works include his writing about economic terms and research into job classifications. Jack received his BS from Hampshire College.
