Post job

Commodity broker vs securities trader

The differences between commodity brokers and securities traders can be seen in a few details. Each job has different responsibilities and duties. Additionally, a securities trader has an average salary of $116,767, which is higher than the $63,317 average annual salary of a commodity broker.

The top three skills for a commodity broker include commodities, market analysis and risk management. The most important skills for a securities trader are securities, risk management, and fixed income.

Commodity broker vs securities trader overview

Commodity BrokerSecurities Trader
Yearly salary$63,317$116,767
Hourly rate$30.44$56.14
Growth rate10%10%
Number of jobs1,9373,668
Job satisfaction--
Most common degreeBachelor's Degree, 77%Bachelor's Degree, 80%
Average age4343
Years of experience--

Commodity broker vs securities trader salary

Commodity brokers and securities traders have different pay scales, as shown below.

Commodity BrokerSecurities Trader
Average salary$63,317$116,767
Salary rangeBetween $39,000 And $102,000Between $68,000 And $197,000
Highest paying CityNew York, NYNew York, NY
Highest paying stateNew YorkNew York
Best paying companyICAPCredit Agricole CIB
Best paying industryFinanceFinance

Differences between commodity broker and securities trader education

There are a few differences between a commodity broker and a securities trader in terms of educational background:

Commodity BrokerSecurities Trader
Most common degreeBachelor's Degree, 77%Bachelor's Degree, 80%
Most common majorBusinessFinance
Most common collegeUniversity of PennsylvaniaUniversity of Pennsylvania

Commodity broker vs securities trader demographics

Here are the differences between commodity brokers' and securities traders' demographics:

Commodity BrokerSecurities Trader
Average age4343
Gender ratioMale, 82.6% Female, 17.4%Male, 85.1% Female, 14.9%
Race ratioBlack or African American, 5.7% Unknown, 4.1% Hispanic or Latino, 12.0% Asian, 9.8% White, 68.2% American Indian and Alaska Native, 0.2%Black or African American, 5.8% Unknown, 4.1% Hispanic or Latino, 12.1% Asian, 11.4% White, 66.4% American Indian and Alaska Native, 0.2%
LGBT Percentage6%6%

Differences between commodity broker and securities trader duties and responsibilities

Commodity broker example responsibilities.

  • Manage and execute physical/financial grains book as well as base metal arbitrage portfolio.
  • Trade on the NYFE, CME, and CBOT exchanges.
  • Provide research and analysis of prospective exchange trade funds for listing on the AMEX.
  • Support the firm's compliance director with records verification pertaining to audits, inquiries, and questions concerning NYSE floor operations.
  • Reorganize the UBS NYSE floor structure utilizing state-of-the-art technology and consolidating booth spaces.
  • Solicit profitable freight brokerage business by marketing transportation capability via direct sales calls, telephone and direct mail marketing activity.
  • Show more

Securities trader example responsibilities.

  • Research, analyze, and invest in equities in order to achieve short term capital gains.
  • Manage business, sales, marketing, international negotiation and communication for a commodities business.
  • Collaborate with partners in trading domestic equities, international equities, corporate bonds, and sovereign debt instruments.
  • Carry out NYSE and NASDAQ equity trading on behalf of institutional clientele and register investment advisors.
  • Execute institutional equity orders on both an agency and proprietary basis in strict accordance to FINRA regulations and establish company guidelines.
  • Trade multiple products on SGX, CBOT, CME, HKFE, TSE, EUREX and LIFFE exchanges.
  • Show more

Commodity broker vs securities trader skills

Common commodity broker skills
  • Commodities, 17%
  • Market Analysis, 8%
  • Risk Management, 5%
  • Technical Analysis, 4%
  • Client Accounts, 4%
  • NFA, 4%
Common securities trader skills
  • Securities, 18%
  • Risk Management, 11%
  • Fixed Income, 8%
  • Equities, 8%
  • Financial Statements, 6%
  • Bonds, 5%