Post job

Trader vs commodity broker

The differences between traders and commodity brokers can be seen in a few details. Each job has different responsibilities and duties. Additionally, a trader has an average salary of $90,179, which is higher than the $63,317 average annual salary of a commodity broker.

The top three skills for a trader include portfolio, financial markets and derivative. The most important skills for a commodity broker are commodities, market analysis, and risk management.

Trader vs commodity broker overview

TraderCommodity Broker
Yearly salary$90,179$63,317
Hourly rate$43.36$30.44
Growth rate10%10%
Number of jobs17,3511,937
Job satisfaction--
Most common degreeBachelor's Degree, 78%Bachelor's Degree, 77%
Average age4343
Years of experience--

Trader vs commodity broker salary

Traders and commodity brokers have different pay scales, as shown below.

TraderCommodity Broker
Average salary$90,179$63,317
Salary rangeBetween $56,000 And $144,000Between $39,000 And $102,000
Highest paying CityWhite Plains, NYNew York, NY
Highest paying stateNew YorkNew York
Best paying companyThe CitadelICAP
Best paying industryFinanceFinance

Differences between trader and commodity broker education

There are a few differences between a trader and a commodity broker in terms of educational background:

TraderCommodity Broker
Most common degreeBachelor's Degree, 78%Bachelor's Degree, 77%
Most common majorFinanceBusiness
Most common collegeUniversity of PennsylvaniaUniversity of Pennsylvania

Trader vs commodity broker demographics

Here are the differences between traders' and commodity brokers' demographics:

TraderCommodity Broker
Average age4343
Gender ratioMale, 82.1% Female, 17.9%Male, 82.6% Female, 17.4%
Race ratioBlack or African American, 5.5% Unknown, 4.1% Hispanic or Latino, 11.5% Asian, 12.4% White, 66.2% American Indian and Alaska Native, 0.2%Black or African American, 5.7% Unknown, 4.1% Hispanic or Latino, 12.0% Asian, 9.8% White, 68.2% American Indian and Alaska Native, 0.2%
LGBT Percentage6%6%

Differences between trader and commodity broker duties and responsibilities

Trader example responsibilities.

  • Manage Smithtown branch office ensuring compliance with NASD regulations.
  • Manage and hedge generation within PJM, MISO, and ERCOT.
  • Manage options trading to ensure a positive ROI within a volatile market.
  • Initiate and manage financial, physical and virtual trades resulting in a positive PnL.
  • Manage products with the supply chain warehouses and interface with both corporate logistics and common carriers.
  • Coordinate MBS and whole loan delivers to ensure settlements are achieve to minimize extension and pair off fees.
  • Show more

Commodity broker example responsibilities.

  • Manage and execute physical/financial grains book as well as base metal arbitrage portfolio.
  • Trade on the NYFE, CME, and CBOT exchanges.
  • Provide research and analysis of prospective exchange trade funds for listing on the AMEX.
  • Support the firm's compliance director with records verification pertaining to audits, inquiries, and questions concerning NYSE floor operations.
  • Reorganize the UBS NYSE floor structure utilizing state-of-the-art technology and consolidating booth spaces.
  • Solicit profitable freight brokerage business by marketing transportation capability via direct sales calls, telephone and direct mail marketing activity.
  • Show more

Trader vs commodity broker skills

Common trader skills
  • Portfolio, 13%
  • Financial Markets, 6%
  • Derivative, 5%
  • Fixed Income, 5%
  • Equities, 4%
  • Securities, 4%
Common commodity broker skills
  • Commodities, 17%
  • Market Analysis, 8%
  • Risk Management, 5%
  • Technical Analysis, 4%
  • Client Accounts, 4%
  • NFA, 4%