Selective Insurance underwriter salary

Zippia score 4.9

Average Selective Insurance underwriter salary

$61,565yearly

$29.69 hourly rate

Entry-level Selective Insurance underwriter salary

$37,000 yearly

Updated April 5, 2024

How much does Selective Insurance pay underwriters?

The average salary for Selective Insurance underwriters is $61,565 per year. Selective Insurance underwriter salaries range between $37,000 to $101,000 per year. Selective Insurance underwriters earn 0% less than the national average salary for underwriters of $61,751.

Location impacts how much a underwriter at Selective Insurance can expect to make. Underwriters at Selective Insurance make the most in Rowe, MA, Fine, NY, and Glastonbury, CT.

How much does Selective Insurance pay underwriters by location?

Selective Insurance pays underwriters the most in Rowe, MA, Fine, NY, and Glastonbury, CT. Additionally, cities like Allentown and Branchville also report highly competitive salaries for underwriters at Selective Insurance.

Underwriter Selective Insurance salary by location

Rank	City	Avg. salary	Hourly rate
1	Rowe, MA	$99,321	$47.75
2	Fine, NY	$92,228	$44.34
3	Glastonbury, CT	$87,187	$41.92
4	Allentown, PA	$83,873	$40.32
5	Branchville, NJ	$79,596	$38.27
6	Bowne, MI	$65,687	$31.58
7	Enon, VA	$65,321	$31.40
8	Mundelein, IL	$62,442	$30.02
9	Fullerton, CA	$56,763	$27.29
10	Tony, WI	$55,975	$26.91

Highest-paid Selective Insurance underwriters by job level

Rank	Job title	Average salary	Hourly rate	Job openings
1	Securities Underwriter	$92,150	$44	-
2	Underwriter Solicitation Director	$91,414	$44	-
3	Investment Underwriter	$91,021	$44	-
4	Automobile And Property Underwriter	$90,355	$43	-
5	Underwriting Manager	$89,780	$43	2
6	Bond Underwriter	$87,962	$42	8
7	Health Underwriter	$87,651	$42	-
8	Marine Underwriter	$87,435	$42	-
9	Life Underwriter	$87,002	$42	-
10	Administrative Underwriter	$86,746	$42	-

Show more salaries

Recent salaries for underwriters at selective insurance

Job	Location	Date added	Salary
Production Underwriter-Remote Ohio/West Virginia/Western Pennsylvania	Enon, OH	06/28/2025	$84,000
E&S Assistant Underwriter-AZ, CT, PA, NJ, NC (Hybrid)	Scottsdale, AZ	06/21/2025	$41,100
Production Underwriter (Remote)	Noank, CT	05/24/2025	$84,000
Production Underwriter (Remote)	VT	05/23/2025	$84,000
E&S Underwriter-Hybrid	Scottsdale, AZ	04/27/2025	$63,000

Underwriter salary at Selective Insurance competitors

Rank	Company	Average salary	Hourly rate	Job openings
1	Chubb	$92,146	$44	205
2	Utica National Insurance Group	$80,456	$39	-
3	Delta Dental of Virginia	$78,893	$38	-
4	The Travelers Companies	$74,711	$36	18
5	The Hanover Insurance Group	$71,645	$34	49
6	Scottsdale Insurance	$71,399	$34	-
7	CareFirst BlueCross BlueShield	$69,362	$33	1
8	NGM Insurance Company, Inc.	$64,548	$31	-
9	Donegal Insurance Group	$62,186	$30	-
10	Mercury Insurance	$57,905	$28	-
11	Foremost Insurance	$56,047	$27	-
12	Accident Fund Insurance	$55,163	$27	-
13	RVOS Insurance Group	$54,232	$26	-
14	Kingsway America	$52,715	$25	-
15	Citizens Property Insurance	$49,908	$24	-
16	QBE Insurance Group	$49,810	$24	9
17	Missouri Employers Mutual	$49,598	$24	-
18	HealthNow	$48,574	$23	-
19	MVP Health Care	$48,529	$23	-
20	GuideOne Insurance	$43,344	$21	21

Show more underwriter salaries at Selective Insurance competitors.