Selective Insurance claim specialist salary

Zippia score 4.9

Average Selective Insurance claim specialist salary

$58,589yearly

$20.75 hourly rate

Entry-level Selective Insurance claim specialist salary

$37,000 yearly

Updated April 5, 2024

How much does Selective Insurance pay claim specialists?

The average salary for Selective Insurance claim specialists is $58,589 per year. Selective Insurance claim specialist salaries range between $37,000 to $90,000 per year. Selective Insurance claim specialists earn 36% more than the national average salary for claim specialists of $43,164.

Location impacts how much a claim specialist at Selective Insurance can expect to make. Claim specialists at Selective Insurance make the most in Glastonbury, CT, Rowe, MA, and Branchville, NJ.

How much does Selective Insurance pay claim specialists by location?

Selective Insurance pays claim specialists the most in Glastonbury, CT, Rowe, MA, and Branchville, NJ. Additionally, cities like Allentown and Fine also report highly competitive salaries for claim specialists at Selective Insurance.

Claim specialist Selective Insurance salary by location

Rank	City	Avg. salary	Hourly rate
1	Glastonbury, CT	$92,701	$44.57
2	Rowe, MA	$88,744	$42.67
3	Branchville, NJ	$87,413	$42.03
4	Allentown, PA	$76,988	$37.01
5	Fine, NY	$75,316	$36.21
6	Enon, VA	$66,110	$31.78
7	Bowne, MI	$65,632	$31.55
8	Fullerton, CA	$58,276	$28.02
9	Tony, WI	$56,249	$27.04
10	Indianapolis, IN	$54,874	$26.38

Highest-paid Selective Insurance claim specialists by job level

Rank	Job title	Average salary	Hourly rate	Job openings
1	Senior Claims Analyst	$109,718	$53	-
2	Senior Claims Specialist	$95,791	$46	-
3	Claims Analyst	$89,052	$43	-
4	Senior Claims Examiner	$85,346	$41	-
5	Claims Benefit Specialist	$81,072	$39	-
6	Senior Claims Adjuster	$76,919	$37	-
7	Liability Claims Examiner	$63,283	$30	-
8	Specialist	$53,106	$26	-
9	Adjuster	$52,471	$25	-
10	Subrogation Specialist	$51,871	$25	-

Show more salaries

Recent salaries for claim specialists at selective insurance

Job	Location	Date added	Salary
Property Field Claims Specialist-Atlanta, GA (Remote)	Nunez, GA	05/24/2025	$71,000
Property Field Claims Specialist-Atlanta, GA (Remote)	Nunez, GA	03/14/2025	$71,000
Property Field Claims Specialist-Atlanta, GA (Remote)	Nunez, GA	02/11/2025	$71,000

Claim specialist salary at Selective Insurance competitors

Rank	Company	Average salary	Hourly rate	Job openings
1	Chubb	$92,513	$44	77
2	Utica National Insurance Group	$78,199	$38	12
3	The Travelers Companies	$72,986	$35	128
4	The Hanover Insurance Group	$71,092	$34	18
5	Scottsdale Insurance	$68,905	$33	-
6	Donegal Insurance Group	$58,841	$28	2
7	Delta Dental of Virginia	$58,574	$28	-
8	CareFirst BlueCross BlueShield	$57,938	$28	2
9	NGM Insurance Company, Inc.	$56,885	$27	-
10	Mercury Insurance	$56,844	$27	21
11	RVOS Insurance Group	$55,447	$27	-
12	Accident Fund Insurance	$54,984	$26	-
13	Kingsway America	$54,517	$26	-
14	QBE Insurance Group	$52,157	$25	8
15	Foremost Insurance	$52,098	$25	-
16	Missouri Employers Mutual	$51,070	$25	-
17	MVP Health Care	$50,999	$25	4
18	GuideOne Insurance	$50,901	$24	-
19	HealthNow	$47,430	$23	-
20	Citizens Property Insurance	$43,345	$21	-

Show more claim specialist salaries at Selective Insurance competitors.