Utility mechanic supervisor vs maintenance manager

The differences between utility mechanic supervisors and maintenance managers can be seen in a few details. Each job has different responsibilities and duties. It typically takes 2-4 years to become both a utility mechanic supervisor and a maintenance manager. Additionally, a maintenance manager has an average salary of $72,269, which is higher than the $45,666 average annual salary of a utility mechanic supervisor.

The top three skills for a utility mechanic supervisor include hand tools, preventive maintenance and HVAC. The most important skills for a maintenance manager are OSHA, customer service, and plumbing.

Utility mechanic supervisor vs maintenance manager overview

	Utility Mechanic Supervisor	Maintenance Manager
Yearly salary	$45,666	$72,269
Hourly rate	$21.95	$34.74
Growth rate	5%	7%
Number of jobs	65,655	61,748
Job satisfaction	-	-
Most common degree	High School Diploma, 31%	Bachelor's Degree, 41%
Average age	49	49
Years of experience	4	4

What does a utility mechanic supervisor do?

A utility mechanic supervisor supervises workers who repair damaged and faulty utility systems. They are responsible for supervising mechanics while they are troubleshooting technical difficulties or repairing mechanical failures. They are required to optimize the repair and maintenance of electrical, HVAC, and plumbing equipment systems. Furthermore, they may also be expected to carry out chemical analysis of water treatments for boilers, HVAC softeners, and purifying water systems.

What does a maintenance manager do?

A maintenance manager's role is to lead and oversee the workflow and workforce involved in the upkeep of a building or establishment. Duties include ensuring that all aspects are operational and in good condition. Some of the responsibilities of a maintenance manager are to supervise all installation and repairs in the building, arrange schedules for regular inspection, devise strategies, obtain cost-effective materials, and hire trustworthy contractors. Furthermore, maintenance managers must coordinate with all workforce involved and ensure that all operations adhere to the company's policies and regulations.

Utility mechanic supervisor vs maintenance manager salary

Utility mechanic supervisors and maintenance managers have different pay scales, as shown below.

	Utility Mechanic Supervisor	Maintenance Manager
Average salary	$45,666	$72,269
Salary range	Between $33,000 And $62,000	Between $47,000 And $109,000
Highest paying City	Plainfield, NJ	Sacramento, CA
Highest paying state	New Jersey	New Jersey
Best paying company	Reckitt Benckiser	BP America Inc
Best paying industry	Utilities	Government

Differences between utility mechanic supervisor and maintenance manager education

There are a few differences between a utility mechanic supervisor and a maintenance manager in terms of educational background:

	Utility Mechanic Supervisor	Maintenance Manager
Most common degree	High School Diploma, 31%	Bachelor's Degree, 41%
Most common major	Automotive Technology	Business
Most common college	SUNY College of Technology at Alfred	SUNY College of Technology at Alfred

Utility mechanic supervisor vs maintenance manager demographics

Here are the differences between utility mechanic supervisors' and maintenance managers' demographics:

	Utility Mechanic Supervisor	Maintenance Manager
Average age	49	49
Gender ratio	Male, 95.7% Female, 4.3%	Male, 94.0% Female, 6.0%
Race ratio	Black or African American, 8.2% Unknown, 4.5% Hispanic or Latino, 15.6% Asian, 2.1% White, 68.4% American Indian and Alaska Native, 1.2%	Black or African American, 8.3% Unknown, 4.5% Hispanic or Latino, 15.9% Asian, 2.1% White, 67.9% American Indian and Alaska Native, 1.2%
LGBT Percentage	4%	4%

Differences between utility mechanic supervisor and maintenance manager duties and responsibilities

Utility mechanic supervisor example responsibilities.

Optimize the repair and maintenance of HVAC, electrical and plumbing equipment and systems.
Maintain and repair motors, controllers, pumps, valves, and blowers.
Perform simple chemical analysis of water treatments for boilers, HVAC, softeners, purify water system, etc.
Supervise mechanics in the diagnosis and repair of technical difficulties, installation and in mechanical failures of military equipment.
Provide effective troubleshooting of mechanical issues, utilizes mechanical technology, including knowledge and understanding of diagnostics.

Maintenance manager example responsibilities.

Select, contract, and manage vendors for MRO supplies or specialize maintenance services.
Maintain OEE on all equipment to achieve run performance goals and to produce 500MM pounds of finish product a year.
Arrange and schedule preventative and predictive maintenance activities to ensure maximum plant operational effectiveness using the CMMS system.
Reduce conversion expenses for plant maintenance by developing and implementing cost control strategies and the implementation CMMS base preventive maintenance program.
Implement vending machines plant wide for small electronic switches and cables.
Head of the maintenance department for a busy plastics sheeting extrusion plant.

Utility mechanic supervisor vs maintenance manager skills

Common utility mechanic supervisor skills

Hand Tools, 26%
Preventive Maintenance, 9%
HVAC, 8%
Troubleshoot, 5%
Plumbing, 5%
Ladders, 4%

Common maintenance manager skills

OSHA, 7%
Customer Service, 6%
Plumbing, 6%
HVAC, 6%
Continuous Improvement, 5%
CMMS, 4%

Utility Mechanic Supervisor vs. similar jobs

Utility Mechanic Supervisor related careers

Utility Mechanic Supervisor related jobs

What similar roles do

Zippia Careers
Installation, Maintenance and Repair Industry
Utility Mechanic Supervisor
Utility Mechanic Supervisor vs Maintenance Manager

Updated January 8, 2025

Browse installation, maintenance and repair jobs