Post job

Commodity analyst vs purchasing supervisor

The differences between commodity analysts and purchasing supervisors can be seen in a few details. Each job has different responsibilities and duties. It typically takes 4-6 years to become both a commodity analyst and a purchasing supervisor. Additionally, a commodity analyst has an average salary of $87,261, which is higher than the $68,702 average annual salary of a purchasing supervisor.

The top three skills for a commodity analyst include risk management, commodities and macro. The most important skills for a purchasing supervisor are purchase orders, MRP, and supplier performance.

Commodity analyst vs purchasing supervisor overview

Commodity AnalystPurchasing Supervisor
Yearly salary$87,261$68,702
Hourly rate$41.95$33.03
Growth rate11%-6%
Number of jobs11,13019,412
Job satisfaction--
Most common degreeBachelor's Degree, 79%Bachelor's Degree, 62%
Average age4848
Years of experience66

What does a commodity analyst do?

A commodity analyst focuses on the raw material part of the stock market. This job can range from analyzing oil and electricity to soybeans and fruits. Typical tasks of a commodity analyst include monitoring the commodities and market industries, analyzing financial information, and drafting accurate reports for investors. This analyst requires at least a bachelor's degree in finance, economics, or a related field. Other qualifications include using computer software, a thorough knowledge of economics, and analytical skills.

What does a purchasing supervisor do?

A purchasing supervisor orders supplies, equipment, and materials from vendors by buyers. The purchasing supervisors assess, select, and build relationships with the vendors. They do the negotiation for the contracts of goods and services. It is their job to review the purchase orders for accuracy and ensure to obtain the best prices. The skills supervisors need to develop include marketing, communication, leadership, and management. They should also know about purchasing products and services.

Commodity analyst vs purchasing supervisor salary

Commodity analysts and purchasing supervisors have different pay scales, as shown below.

Commodity AnalystPurchasing Supervisor
Average salary$87,261$68,702
Salary rangeBetween $63,000 And $119,000Between $45,000 And $104,000
Highest paying CityBoston, MASan Francisco, CA
Highest paying stateMassachusettsCalifornia
Best paying companyAppleCDW
Best paying industryFinanceTechnology

Differences between commodity analyst and purchasing supervisor education

There are a few differences between a commodity analyst and a purchasing supervisor in terms of educational background:

Commodity AnalystPurchasing Supervisor
Most common degreeBachelor's Degree, 79%Bachelor's Degree, 62%
Most common majorBusinessBusiness
Most common collegeUniversity of PennsylvaniaUniversity of Pennsylvania

Commodity analyst vs purchasing supervisor demographics

Here are the differences between commodity analysts' and purchasing supervisors' demographics:

Commodity AnalystPurchasing Supervisor
Average age4848
Gender ratioMale, 63.6% Female, 36.4%Male, 57.4% Female, 42.6%
Race ratioBlack or African American, 9.1% Unknown, 4.4% Hispanic or Latino, 12.4% Asian, 7.8% White, 65.5% American Indian and Alaska Native, 0.8%Black or African American, 9.1% Unknown, 4.4% Hispanic or Latino, 12.5% Asian, 7.8% White, 65.4% American Indian and Alaska Native, 0.8%
LGBT Percentage7%7%

Differences between commodity analyst and purchasing supervisor duties and responsibilities

Commodity analyst example responsibilities.

  • Accomplish the RFQ process, providing cost and availability information on a timely basis.
  • Manage operational risk and cultivate client relationships through OTC commodities trade confirmation across all commodities.
  • Develop detailed databases on supply and demand fundamentals for commodities under review.
  • Assist management with evaluation of restructuring alternatives, procurement of financing, negotiations with multiple constituencies and issuance of new securities.
  • Query expenditures in PeopleSoft to identify categories to leverage through renegotiating company's contracts.
  • Monitor and facilitate flow of automotive material through terminal, coordinating JIT procedures.

Purchasing supervisor example responsibilities.

  • Manage increasing procurement demands of inventory/supplies for manufacturing activities base on an ERP MRP system.
  • Lead and analyze all RFQ's, RFI's and RFP's from different qualify vendors.
  • Interview current and prospective suppliers to determine supplier capabilities, logistics and inventory control and management while negotiate delivery terms.
  • Review requisitions and RFP's, obtain quotations, negotiate pricing, examine bids and award contracts.
  • Assist in the yearly budgeting process including RFQ's and establishing contracts both locally and at the corporate level.
  • Direct large projects by creating RFP's, cost negotiation, and bid analysis on specifications and budget cost provided.
  • Show more

Commodity analyst vs purchasing supervisor skills

Common commodity analyst skills
  • Risk Management, 13%
  • Commodities, 12%
  • Macro, 7%
  • Supplier Performance, 6%
  • VBA, 6%
  • Derivative, 5%
Common purchasing supervisor skills
  • Purchase Orders, 20%
  • MRP, 5%
  • Supplier Performance, 4%
  • Logistics, 4%
  • Corrective Action, 4%
  • On-Time Delivery, 4%

Browse business and financial jobs