Post job

Health care manager vs medical consultant

The differences between health care managers and medical consultants can be seen in a few details. Each job has different responsibilities and duties. It typically takes 4-6 years to become both a health care manager and a medical consultant. Additionally, a medical consultant has an average salary of $194,384, which is higher than the $60,931 average annual salary of a health care manager.

The top three skills for a health care manager include social work, behavioral health and substance abuse. The most important skills for a medical consultant are patients, patient care, and surgery.

Health care manager vs medical consultant overview

Health Care ManagerMedical Consultant
Yearly salary$60,931$194,384
Hourly rate$29.29$93.45
Growth rate28%28%
Number of jobs153,82177,013
Job satisfaction--
Most common degreeBachelor's Degree, 53%Bachelor's Degree, 47%
Average age4747
Years of experience66

What does a health care manager do?

A health care manager is in charge of overseeing the workflow and the workforce in a medical facility. Their responsibilities revolve around planning and organizing services, delegating tasks, managing schedules and budgets, and devising strategies for optimal operations. They must also coordinate with different health care workers within the facility, participate in hiring and training staff, set goals and guidelines, and maintain hospital records. Furthermore, a health care manager must implement the hospital's policies and regulations, even create new ones as needed.

What does a medical consultant do?

A medical consultant assists doctors and other medical staff in running a healthcare facility. They give advice on matters such as salaries, staffing, advertising, safety, patient confidentiality and insurance plan compliance. They are also responsible for gathering and analyzing data, coming up with conclusions, providing recommendations to the employer, helping the institution ensure they are compliant with insurance and safety standards, and offering advice that will help optimize the performance of the health facility.

Health care manager vs medical consultant salary

Health care managers and medical consultants have different pay scales, as shown below.

Health Care ManagerMedical Consultant
Average salary$60,931$194,384
Salary rangeBetween $39,000 And $93,000Between $100,000 And $374,000
Highest paying CityLinden, NJChicago, IL
Highest paying stateConnecticutDelaware
Best paying companyAccentureBerkshire Hathaway
Best paying industryUtilitiesPharmaceutical

Differences between health care manager and medical consultant education

There are a few differences between a health care manager and a medical consultant in terms of educational background:

Health Care ManagerMedical Consultant
Most common degreeBachelor's Degree, 53%Bachelor's Degree, 47%
Most common majorNursingNursing
Most common collegeUniversity of PennsylvaniaUniversity of Pennsylvania

Health care manager vs medical consultant demographics

Here are the differences between health care managers' and medical consultants' demographics:

Health Care ManagerMedical Consultant
Average age4747
Gender ratioMale, 30.2% Female, 69.8%Male, 46.4% Female, 53.6%
Race ratioBlack or African American, 11.6% Unknown, 4.3% Hispanic or Latino, 14.6% Asian, 7.5% White, 61.3% American Indian and Alaska Native, 0.7%Black or African American, 11.7% Unknown, 4.3% Hispanic or Latino, 14.3% Asian, 8.0% White, 61.0% American Indian and Alaska Native, 0.7%
LGBT Percentage12%12%

Differences between health care manager and medical consultant duties and responsibilities

Health care manager example responsibilities.

  • Manage network participation, care with specialty networks, DME providers and transfers to appropriate levels of care.
  • Manage patient care expenditures including but not limit to labor, pharmacy, DME, medical supplies and mileage.
  • Provide oversight of the case management and utilization management staff for the Medicaid population
  • Supervise and conduct employee seminars and training in employee health issues, infection control and CPR.
  • Support sales team in designing population health solutions present in proposals and client facing PowerPoint presentations.
  • Assist members with benefits, PCP referrals and inquires.
  • Show more

Medical consultant example responsibilities.

  • Manage CMS require oversight of in-home, at-risk Medicare member care management programs through chart audit and NCQA on-site visits.
  • Lead the planning, organization, execution, and analysis of coding, billing, HIPAA, and OSHA audits.
  • Provide SharePoint development and administration, budget and financial reporting; manage invoicing; and develop training manuals and user guides.
  • Function as the primary office safety, health, OSHA, HIPPA representative.
  • Experience in dental CPT and ICD-9, as well as medical CPT and ICD-9 coding.
  • Demonstrate knowledge of ICD-9-CM and CPT coding guidelines, medical terminology, anatomy, and physiology.
  • Show more

Health care manager vs medical consultant skills

Common health care manager skills
  • Social Work, 28%
  • Behavioral Health, 10%
  • Substance Abuse, 8%
  • Community Resources, 8%
  • Patients, 5%
  • Utilization Management, 4%
Common medical consultant skills
  • Patients, 22%
  • Patient Care, 10%
  • Surgery, 8%
  • Medical Care, 7%
  • Oncology, 6%
  • Medical Services, 6%

Browse executive management jobs