Post job

Recruitment manager vs personnel manager

The differences between recruitment managers and personnel managers can be seen in a few details. Each job has different responsibilities and duties. It typically takes 4-6 years to become both a recruitment manager and a personnel manager. Additionally, a recruitment manager has an average salary of $87,506, which is higher than the $51,570 average annual salary of a personnel manager.

The top three skills for a recruitment manager include customer service, client relationships and human resources. The most important skills for a personnel manager are disciplinary procedures, human resource functions, and workers compensation.

Recruitment manager vs personnel manager overview

Recruitment ManagerPersonnel Manager
Yearly salary$87,506$51,570
Hourly rate$42.07$24.79
Growth rate7%7%
Number of jobs31,10614,803
Job satisfaction--
Most common degreeBachelor's Degree, 75%Bachelor's Degree, 59%
Average age4747
Years of experience66

Recruitment manager vs personnel manager salary

Recruitment managers and personnel managers have different pay scales, as shown below.

Recruitment ManagerPersonnel Manager
Average salary$87,506$51,570
Salary rangeBetween $57,000 And $134,000Between $37,000 And $70,000
Highest paying CitySan Francisco, CAStamford, CT
Highest paying stateCaliforniaConnecticut
Best paying companyBain & CompanyNutech Information Systems
Best paying industryTechnologyRetail

Differences between recruitment manager and personnel manager education

There are a few differences between a recruitment manager and a personnel manager in terms of educational background:

Recruitment ManagerPersonnel Manager
Most common degreeBachelor's Degree, 75%Bachelor's Degree, 59%
Most common majorBusinessBusiness
Most common collegeNorthwestern UniversityNorthwestern University

Recruitment manager vs personnel manager demographics

Here are the differences between recruitment managers' and personnel managers' demographics:

Recruitment ManagerPersonnel Manager
Average age4747
Gender ratioMale, 47.0% Female, 53.0%Male, 49.3% Female, 50.7%
Race ratioBlack or African American, 7.7% Unknown, 5.1% Hispanic or Latino, 11.1% Asian, 5.7% White, 70.0% American Indian and Alaska Native, 0.4%Black or African American, 7.7% Unknown, 5.1% Hispanic or Latino, 11.1% Asian, 5.7% White, 70.0% American Indian and Alaska Native, 0.4%
LGBT Percentage18%18%

Differences between recruitment manager and personnel manager duties and responsibilities

Recruitment manager example responsibilities.

  • Manage the implementation of online applicant tracking system, ICIMS.
  • Lead RFP process for prefer staffing and background check vendors.
  • Manage pulling resumes off of Jobvite and screen each resume.
  • Manage HRIS to ensure compliance with applicant flow log, I9's, background & reference check, etc.
  • Schedule new hires for sales training and orientation programs, manage PeopleSoft files and on line resume tracking reports.
  • Manage the recruitment budget; approve and track expenses; ensure highest ROI by tracking outputs of events and postings.
  • Show more

Personnel manager example responsibilities.

  • Manage administrative wellness of a crew of 150 sailors.
  • Monitor and manage daily the Kronos timekeeping system for all employees.
  • Manage wage and salary administration and supervise payroll function.
  • Manage compliance review of FLSA classification and analyze headcount and turnover reports and provide recommendations to management regarding appropriate headcount actions.
  • Create policies, procedures, performance management training, benefit enrollment, military screenings and manpower analysis.
  • Prepare quotes and all relate correspondence using PowerPoint.
  • Show more

Recruitment manager vs personnel manager skills

Common recruitment manager skills
  • Customer Service, 18%
  • Client Relationships, 9%
  • Human Resources, 6%
  • Business Development, 6%
  • Recruitment Strategies, 5%
  • Recruitment Process, 4%
Common personnel manager skills
  • Disciplinary Procedures, 11%
  • Human Resource Functions, 5%
  • Workers Compensation, 4%
  • Background Checks, 4%
  • Professional Development, 4%
  • Personnel Policies, 4%

Browse executive management jobs