Post job

Personnel manager vs human resources supervisor

The differences between personnel managers and human resources supervisors can be seen in a few details. Each job has different responsibilities and duties. It typically takes 4-6 years to become both a personnel manager and a human resources supervisor. Additionally, a human resources supervisor has an average salary of $64,757, which is higher than the $51,570 average annual salary of a personnel manager.

The top three skills for a personnel manager include disciplinary procedures, human resource functions and workers compensation. The most important skills for a human resources supervisor are customer service, state laws, and payroll processing.

Personnel manager vs human resources supervisor overview

Personnel ManagerHuman Resources Supervisor
Yearly salary$51,570$64,757
Hourly rate$24.79$31.13
Growth rate7%7%
Number of jobs14,80346,523
Job satisfaction--
Most common degreeBachelor's Degree, 59%Bachelor's Degree, 62%
Average age4747
Years of experience66

Personnel manager vs human resources supervisor salary

Personnel managers and human resources supervisors have different pay scales, as shown below.

Personnel ManagerHuman Resources Supervisor
Average salary$51,570$64,757
Salary rangeBetween $37,000 And $70,000Between $47,000 And $88,000
Highest paying CityStamford, CTSan Francisco, CA
Highest paying stateConnecticutCalifornia
Best paying companyNutech Information SystemsGenentech
Best paying industryRetailManufacturing

Differences between personnel manager and human resources supervisor education

There are a few differences between a personnel manager and a human resources supervisor in terms of educational background:

Personnel ManagerHuman Resources Supervisor
Most common degreeBachelor's Degree, 59%Bachelor's Degree, 62%
Most common majorBusinessBusiness
Most common collegeNorthwestern UniversityUniversity of Pennsylvania

Personnel manager vs human resources supervisor demographics

Here are the differences between personnel managers' and human resources supervisors' demographics:

Personnel ManagerHuman Resources Supervisor
Average age4747
Gender ratioMale, 49.3% Female, 50.7%Male, 35.1% Female, 64.9%
Race ratioBlack or African American, 7.7% Unknown, 5.1% Hispanic or Latino, 11.1% Asian, 5.7% White, 70.0% American Indian and Alaska Native, 0.4%Black or African American, 7.7% Unknown, 5.1% Hispanic or Latino, 11.1% Asian, 5.7% White, 70.0% American Indian and Alaska Native, 0.4%
LGBT Percentage18%18%

Differences between personnel manager and human resources supervisor duties and responsibilities

Personnel manager example responsibilities.

  • Manage administrative wellness of a crew of 150 sailors.
  • Monitor and manage daily the Kronos timekeeping system for all employees.
  • Manage wage and salary administration and supervise payroll function.
  • Manage compliance review of FLSA classification and analyze headcount and turnover reports and provide recommendations to management regarding appropriate headcount actions.
  • Create policies, procedures, performance management training, benefit enrollment, military screenings and manpower analysis.
  • Prepare quotes and all relate correspondence using PowerPoint.
  • Show more

Human resources supervisor example responsibilities.

  • Manage and lead service team initiatives/special projects (i.e., ADP conversion, corporate mergers, and teamwork events).
  • Manage HRIS database system and provide monthly reports to executive management.
  • Manage job-reclassification project, conducting occupational research to determine if job titles are synchronized with FLSA norms.
  • Utilize KRONOS and ADP to import and process payroll.
  • Review all exempt positions to determine classification and conduct audits to ensure FLSA compliance.
  • Maintain all company leave of absence (including work-relate injuries, non work-relate leaves and FMLA, etc .).
  • Show more

Personnel manager vs human resources supervisor skills

Common personnel manager skills
  • Disciplinary Procedures, 11%
  • Human Resource Functions, 5%
  • Workers Compensation, 4%
  • Background Checks, 4%
  • Professional Development, 4%
  • Personnel Policies, 4%
Common human resources supervisor skills
  • Customer Service, 22%
  • State Laws, 9%
  • Payroll Processing, 5%
  • Personnel Actions, 4%
  • HRIS, 4%
  • ISO, 3%

Browse executive management jobs